Skip to content
Briefings are running a touch slower this week while we rebuild the foundations.See roadmap
UK Local Elections 2026
9MAY

Day 3: Reform's 14 councils, 894 seats short

5 min read
17:17UTC

Reform UK won 14 English councils on 7 May but came up 894 seats short of the projection that frightened Westminster. Welsh Labour collapsed to 9 seats exactly as D'Hondt arithmetic predicted. Three electoral systems produced three projection accuracies, and the model that broke is the one Britain uses for everything that matters.

Key takeaway

FPTP models failed under five-party fragmentation; proportional systems remained projectable.

This briefing mapped
Loading map…
Domestic

Reform UK won 14 English councils on 7 May, returning 1,448 councillors against a PollCheck/YouGov MRP projection of 2,342: a 38 percent undershoot, the worst projection failure in modern UK polling.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Reform UK returned 1,448 councillors across 14 English councils on 7 May 2026, finishing 894 seats below the PollCheck/YouGov MRP projection of 2,342 — a 38% undershoot, the worst projection failure in modern UK polling.

MRP (Multilevel Regression and Post-stratification) became Britain's trusted seat-projection tool after Chris Hanretty's 2017 model called the hung Parliament. Its first major test under five-party FPTP fragmentation has just produced an 894-seat error, and every Westminster poll built on the same uniform-swing assumption now carries that error bar. 

Briefing analysis

Welsh Labour governed Wales without interruption from the establishment of the National Assembly in May 1999 until the dissolution of the Senedd ahead of the 2026 election, the longest continuous devolved-government tenure of any party in the UK. Across that 27-year span, Welsh Labour First Ministers (Alun Michael, Rhodri Morgan, Carwyn Jones, Mark Drakeford, Eluned Morgan) operated either as a majority administration, a minority Labour government, a Labour-Lib Dem coalition (2000-2003) or a Labour-Plaid coalition (2007-2011), with Welsh Labour as the senior partner in every configuration.

The 2024 Senedd reform package, negotiated by Drakeford with Plaid Cymru cooperation, expanded the chamber from 60 to 96 seats and replaced the Additional Member System with closed-list D'Hondt proportional representation across 16 six-member constituencies. The reform was justified on capacity grounds (a chamber too small for committee scrutiny) and democratic-renewal grounds (more proportional, larger, more representative).

The arithmetic the new system delivered on 7 May 2026 produced the smallest Welsh Labour group since 1910. Welsh Labour received 12 percent of the vote and won 9 seats out of 96, slightly worse than the projection but inside the modelling error band. Eluned Morgan became the first sitting head of a UK government to lose her own seat in office. The new system worked exactly as PR systems work; the party that wrote the system absorbed the result the system arithmetically produced.

Welsh Labour finished with 9 Senedd seats on 7 May 2026, the smallest Welsh Labour group in any devolved chamber since 1910, after First Minister Eluned Morgan lost her Ceredigion Penfro seat on 6,495 votes.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Welsh Labour finished with 9 Senedd seats on 7 May 2026, the smallest Welsh Labour group in any devolved chamber since 1910, after First Minister Eluned Morgan lost her Ceredigion Penfro seat with 6,495 votes, becoming the first sitting head of a UK government to lose their constituency in office.

Twenty-seven years of continuous Welsh Labour government ended in a single count, with the sitting head of a UK government becoming the first to lose her own constituency in office. The closed-list D'Hondt arithmetic that produced the result is the system Welsh Labour itself wrote and voted into law in the 2024 Senedd Reform package. 

Plaid Cymru leader Rhun ap Iorwerth confirmed on Friday 8 May that Plaid will form a minority government on 43 Senedd seats, with the 2 Wales Green MSs providing confidence and supply.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Plaid Cymru won 43 of 96 Senedd seats on 7 May 2026, with leader Rhun ap Iorwerth confirming on 8 May that Plaid will form a minority government with the 2 Wales Green MSs providing confidence and supply, appointing Ken Skates interim Welsh Labour leader within 24 hours.

A combined Plaid-Green total of 45 seats sits four short of the 49-seat majority threshold, meaning every Senedd division will require vote-by-vote support from Welsh Labour's 9 or the sole Welsh Liberal Democrat. The first First Minister vote falls inside the 28-day window set by Senedd standing orders. 

The SNP won 58 of 129 Holyrood seats on 7 May 2026, seven below the 65-seat threshold John Swinney named as the trigger for a 2028 independence referendum.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

The SNP won 58 of 129 Holyrood seats on 7 May 2026, seven below the 65-seat threshold John Swinney named as the trigger for a 2028 independence referendum, with Holyrood turnout at 53.0%, down 10.5 points on 2021.

Westminster had refused a Section 30 order at 65 seats and has the same answer at 58. The constitutional argument shifts from contested mandate to no mandate at all, structurally compressing independence-referendum demand for the parliamentary term. 

Reform UK entered the Scottish Parliament for the first time on 7 May 2026 with a group of 17 MSPs led by Malcolm Offord, tying with Scottish Labour and overtaking the Scottish Conservatives on 12.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Reform UK entered the Scottish Parliament for the first time on 7 May 2026, winning 17 seats and tying with Scottish Labour on 17, with the Reform Scotland group led by Malcolm Offord, marking the first hard-right populist caucus in Holyrood since devolution began in 1999.

It is the first hard-right populist caucus to sit in Holyrood since devolution began in 1999, and the first Parliament since 1999 in which Conservative-tradition unionism is no longer the principal opposition force on the Scottish right. 

Zoë Garbett won the Hackney mayoralty and Liam Shrivastava won Lewisham from Labour on 7 May 2026, becoming the first Green elected mayors of any London borough; Hackney and Waltham Forest councils flipped Green outright on the same night.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Zoë Garbett won the Hackney mayoralty and Liam Shrivastava won Lewisham from Labour on 7 May 2026, becoming the first Green elected mayors of any London borough; Hackney council moved from Labour 44/Greens 6 to Greens 38/Labour 6, and Waltham Forest moved from Labour 45/Greens 0 to Greens 31/Labour 12.

The Polanski-Deptford targeting strategy launched on 10 April delivered exactly the inner-London Labour citadel breakthrough it was designed for. The Greens now hold four English councils outright and 543 council seats nationally, and gain a council governance record to take into the 2028 cycle. 

Lorna Slater (Scottish Greens) defeated Angus Robertson (SNP) in Edinburgh Central on 7 May 2026, winning 12,680 votes to 7,702 in a constituency Robertson had held since 2016.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Lorna Slater (Scottish Greens) defeated Angus Robertson (SNP) in Edinburgh Central on 12,680 votes to 7,702 on 7 May 2026, the Scottish Greens' second-ever Holyrood constituency seat and the second time the party has taken a seat from a senior SNP figure on the constituency vote.

Robertson is one of three SNP figures most often named as a Swinney succession candidate. His loss removes a senior face from the SNP's post-election landscape and translates The Greens' Polanski-Deptford targeted-constituency strategy north of the border for the first time. 

Reform-controlled Lancashire County Council withdrew from the UK refugee resettlement scheme on Saturday 9 May 2026, two days after the count, the first concrete policy decision from any Reform-controlled authority post-7 May.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Reform-controlled Lancashire County Council withdrew from the UK refugee resettlement scheme on 9 May 2026, two days after switching to Reform UK control following the 7 May elections, the first concrete policy decision from a Reform-controlled authority and the first test of council-level revocation of national-scheme participation.

Lancashire is the first test of whether Home Office scheme participation can be revoked by a county council without primary-legislation override. The Home Office's response will signal what 14 newly Reform-controlled councils can revoke at no central-government cost. 

Reform UK won 41 of 49 Thurrock council seats on 7 May 2026 while Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government commissioners remain in legal control of the council's £1.5bn Section 114 budget.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Reform UK won 41 of 49 Thurrock Council seats on 7 May 2026 while MHCLG commissioners remain in legal control of the council's £1.5bn Section 114 budget, creating an elected mandate without spending authority on the council's largest single budget line.

Reform's Thurrock leadership now holds an elected mandate without spending authority on the largest single line on the council's books. Whether commissioners formally challenge a Reform-led decision is the first direct test of the commissioner-mandate boundary in UK local government. 

Norfolk County Council produced a hung result on 7 May 2026, with Reform UK on 40 of 84 seats, three short of a majority, and Restore Britain's Great Yarmouth First slate on 9, denying any two-party combination including Reform a working majority.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Norfolk County Council produced a hung result on 7 May 2026, with Reform UK winning 40 of 84 seats, three short of a majority; Great Yarmouth First (Restore Britain affiliate) took 9 seats, with the Liberal Democrats on 13, Greens on 12, and Conservatives on 8, meaning no two-party combination including Reform reaches the 43-seat majority threshold.

PollCheck projected Reform control of Norfolk; the Restore Britain split denied it. Norfolk's bin collections, schools admissions and adult social care commissioning now require multi-party coalition negotiation on every full-council vote, with no other party signalling willingness to coalesce with Reform

Reform UK's councillor base tripled in twelve months from 678 elected in 2025 to 2,126 after 7 May 2026, but the prior attrition rate of roughly one in ten projects a 200-plus annual departure pipeline across the expanded estate.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Reform UK's councillor base tripled in twelve months from 678 elected in 2025 to 2,126 after 7 May 2026, but the party's prior attrition rate of 65 out of 677 2025 councillors quitting or being expelled within a year projects a 200-plus annual departure pipeline across the expanded estate.

Reform now scales the same chief-executive disputes and lawful-advice friction the LGA flagged at its 2025 cohort across an estate three times the size, with its strongest councils carrying the burden of departure replacement. 

Reform UK won 58 of 75 seats on Sunderland and 58 of 63 on Wakefield on 7 May 2026, ending 50 years of continuous Labour control and reducing the Wakefield Labour group from 48 seats to 1.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Sunderland fell to Reform on 7 May 2026 with a Reform group of 58 of 75 seats and Labour cut from 49 to 5, ending 50 years of continuous Labour control; Wakefield delivered Reform 58 of 63 seats reducing Labour from 48 to 1, the most extreme single-council collapse of the night.

The most extreme single-council seat swings of the night both landed in Leave-voting metropolitan boroughs where PollCheck applied a council-specific override to its uniform-swing model. Council tax decisions, planning policy and adult social care commissioning across two cities of 700,000 people change hands immediately. 

Closing comments

Direction: sideways-to-up on governance tension; down on polling industry credibility. The governance escalation mechanism is Lancashire. If MHCLG allows Lancashire's refugee-scheme withdrawal to stand without intervention, it establishes a precedent that Reform-controlled councils can exit national partnership schemes unilaterally. If MHCLG intervenes, it creates the first formal confrontation between a Reform county council and a Labour central government, with legal and political consequences for both sides. The decision point is MHCLG Secretary of State within the next 30 days. On the independence front, Swinney has committed to a Section 30 vote on the first Holyrood sitting day post-appointment. Westminster's refusal is pre-stated. The escalation mechanism is whether the SNP-Greens Programme for Government offers enough to hold the coalition together through a budget that the IFS has already found unfunded by £1.4bn annually. On polling methodology: the British Polling Council has no standing review timetable for MRP performance. The 38% undershoot will generate member-firm pressure for a structural post-mortem; the timeline for any published methodology review is 3-6 months.

Different Perspectives
Reform UK
Reform UK
Nigel Farage claimed 7 May as a historic breakthrough, pointing to 1,448 new councillors and 14 councils won from a near-zero base. The internal reckoning is that transition teams built for 22 councils must now govern 14, and three of those 14 produced immediate governance disputes.
Plaid Cymru
Plaid Cymru
Rhun ap Iorwerth confirmed on 8 May that Plaid would attempt to govern Wales as a minority, ruling out immediate coalition talks and naming budget priorities as the test of cross-party support. The 43-seat result leaves Plaid six seats short of the 49-seat majority threshold.
Scottish National Party (SNP)
Scottish National Party (SNP)
John Swinney committed to a Section 30 vote on the first Holyrood sitting day post-appointment and a draft referendum bill within 100 days, reframing the 58-seat result as a working mandate despite missing his own 65-seat trigger. Westminster's pre-stated refusal of a Section 30 order means the constitutional confrontation is now a matter of timing.
UK Labour Government
UK Labour Government
Keir Starmer's government faces the immediate test of whether to intervene in Lancashire's withdrawal from the UK refugee resettlement scheme and the longer question of how to respond if the SNP tables a Section 30 vote. MHCLG's posture on Reform-controlled councils sets the template for the next four years of divided local government.
Green Party
Green Party
Zack Polanski's campaign delivered the Hackney and Lewisham mayoralties and both councils, plus 543 English council seats, establishing the first Green governing base in outer London. The 153-seat MRP undershoot was attributed to FPTP tactical dynamics in marginal wards rather than a polling error in vote share.