Skip to content
Briefings are running a touch slower this week while we rebuild the foundations.See roadmap
UK Local Elections 2026
9MAY

Slater takes Edinburgh Central from SNP

3 min read
17:17UTC

Lorna Slater (Scottish Greens) defeated Angus Robertson (SNP) in Edinburgh Central on 7 May 2026, winning 12,680 votes to 7,702 in a constituency Robertson had held since 2016.

PoliticsDeveloping
Key takeaway

The Greens flipped a flagship SNP seat using the same mechanic that took Hackney and Lewisham from Labour.

Lorna Slater, co-leader of the Scottish Greens, defeated Angus Robertson of the Scottish National Party (SNP) in Edinburgh Central on Thursday 7 May 2026, winning 12,680 votes to Robertson's 7,702. The 4,978-vote margin is one of the largest single-constituency Green wins on a constituency vote in Holyrood history. It is the Scottish Greens' second-ever Holyrood constituency seat and the second time the party has taken a constituency seat from a senior SNP figure on the constituency rather than the regional-list ballot.

Robertson served as Scotland's external affairs secretary and held Edinburgh Central since 2016. He had been one of three figures most often named as a successor to John Swinney in the SNP's post-election leadership conversation. His departure narrows the field of internal challengers and removes a Yes campaign veteran whose 2014 referendum role gave him a profile beyond the parliamentary group. The SNP's caretaker administration (event-03) now manages a leadership succession with a thinner bench than the morning of the count.

The Slater win is the northern translation of the Green Party's Polanski-Deptford targeting strategy launched on 10 April . The Cliftonville Kent by-election on 9 April previewed the mechanic at single-ward scale ; the swing-margin numbers sit on the London-Greens page (event-06). Edinburgh Central, with its high private-rented-sector concentration and tenant-friendly demographics, fits the same template The Greens used to flip Hackney and Lewisham (event-06).

The 12,680-to-7,702 margin matters beyond the seat. SNP candidates in adjacent Lothians constituencies will read it as evidence that The Greens can take seats off the SNP rather than function as a list-vote ally, which changes the SNP's own list strategy in 2030. The Scottish Greens enter the new Parliament with 15 seats (event-04) and a constituency win against a senior SNP figure: the combination gives them leverage over an SNP minority administration disproportionate to the seat-count differential.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Lorna Slater is the co-leader of the Scottish Greens. Angus Robertson was a senior SNP politician who many expected to become the next SNP leader. On 7 May, Slater beat Robertson in Edinburgh Central, a constituency in the centre of Edinburgh, by 4,978 votes. This is only the second time in the Scottish Parliament's entire history that a Green candidate has won a local constituency seat (as opposed to a regional list seat). It also removes Robertson from Holyrood, weakening the SNP's internal talent pool at a sensitive political moment.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Robertson's loss has two structural causes distinct from the general SNP performance. First, Edinburgh Central is geographically adjacent to several large infrastructure and development projects where SNP planning decisions drew sustained local opposition. Robertson, as a Cabinet-level figure in successive SNP governments, carried direct accountability for those decisions in a way a backbench SNP MS would not.

Second, the Green-to-Plaid migration that reduced Wales Green MSs from 10 to 2 had an inverse effect in Scotland: Green voters in Edinburgh Central who in 2021 might have voted SNP to keep their candidate's seat did not need to this time, as the Greens were both standing a strong local candidate and competing seriously on the constituency vote.

What could happen next?
  • Consequence

    Robertson is removed from Holyrood, eliminating him from the SNP's internal succession planning at a moment when Swinney's leadership faces pressure after the 58-seat result.

  • Precedent

    Second-ever Green constituency win in Holyrood confirms the party can target and win individual seats in high-profile contests, changing how the Greens campaign in 2031.

First Reported In

Update #7 · Reform's 14 councils, 894 seats short

Holyrood Magazine· 9 May 2026
Read original
Different Perspectives
Green Party
Green Party
Zack Polanski's campaign delivered the Hackney and Lewisham mayoralties and both councils, plus 543 English council seats, establishing the first Green governing base in outer London. The 153-seat MRP undershoot was attributed to FPTP tactical dynamics in marginal wards rather than a polling error in vote share.
UK Labour Government
UK Labour Government
Keir Starmer's government faces the immediate test of whether to intervene in Lancashire's withdrawal from the UK refugee resettlement scheme and the longer question of how to respond if the SNP tables a Section 30 vote. MHCLG's posture on Reform-controlled councils sets the template for the next four years of divided local government.
Scottish National Party (SNP)
Scottish National Party (SNP)
John Swinney committed to a Section 30 vote on the first Holyrood sitting day post-appointment and a draft referendum bill within 100 days, reframing the 58-seat result as a working mandate despite missing his own 65-seat trigger. Westminster's pre-stated refusal of a Section 30 order means the constitutional confrontation is now a matter of timing.
Plaid Cymru
Plaid Cymru
Rhun ap Iorwerth confirmed on 8 May that Plaid would attempt to govern Wales as a minority, ruling out immediate coalition talks and naming budget priorities as the test of cross-party support. The 43-seat result leaves Plaid six seats short of the 49-seat majority threshold.
Reform UK
Reform UK
Nigel Farage claimed 7 May as a historic breakthrough, pointing to 1,448 new councillors and 14 councils won from a near-zero base. The internal reckoning is that transition teams built for 22 councils must now govern 14, and three of those 14 produced immediate governance disputes.
Wales Governance Centre
Wales Governance Centre
The Centre framed Wales's mid-campaign Green-to-Plaid consolidation as 'consolidation, not conversion' in April, meaning voters did not migrate ideologically but regrouped tactically inside the same bloc because closed-list PR made it arithmetically rational. The final MRP result confirms that framing.