Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Edinburgh Council
AI-generated illustration
OrganisationGB

Edinburgh Council

Local planning authority for the City of Edinburgh.

City of Edinburgh Council by-elections held on 3 September 2026 cost the SNP two seats, The Scotsman reported: Labour's Ruth Elliott won Southside/Newington and the Scottish Greens' Lorenzo Martinico took Portobello/Craigmillar.

Last refreshed: 22 October 2026 · Appears in 2 active topics

Key Question

Why did Edinburgh Council's data centre refusal end up needing a full environmental assessment anyway?

Timeline for Edinburgh Council

#18 22 Sept

Declared two by-election results on 4 September

UK Local Elections 2026: Marra's MSPs vote for right to decide
#13 11 Aug

Refused planning permission in principle for the 212.42 MW scheme

Data Centres: Boom and Backlash: 212 MW Edinburgh appeal now needs an EIA
View full timeline →

Background

City of Edinburgh Council is the unitary local authority for Scotland's capital. Its 63 councillors represent 17 multi-member wards and are elected by single transferable vote, so administrations usually rest on more than one party. It runs schools, housing, social care, roads and waste services, and acts as the city's planning authority.

That planning role brought it into a long dispute over data centres. On 9 February 2026 it refused planning permission in principle for a 212.42 MW scheme at South Gyle. The developer, Shelborn Drummond, appealed to the Scottish Government's Planning and Environmental Appeals Division on 31 March. A screening direction on 30 July overturned the council's view that no environmental impact assessment was needed, and on 12 August the developer's agent confirmed one would be prepared. The case went on hold on 11 August with a target decision date of 8 September.

By-elections in September 2026 showed the council's own chamber shifting away from the SNP.

Key Issues
Council by-elections

Two wards slipped away from the SNP

The council declared both results on 4 September 2026. Elliott polled 2,153 votes in Southside/Newington, and Martinico won Portobello/Craigmillar with 1,781. The Scotsman reported that each seat had been held by the SNP.

The gains landed in a month that reshaped Scottish Labour. Michael Marra won the party's leadership on 19 September, beating Joe Fagan by 4,266 votes to 2,485, and three days later Labour's 17 MSPs voted as one for John Swinney's right-to-decide motion at Holyrood. For the council, the results add a Labour member and a Green one to a chamber elected by single transferable vote, where no party governs alone.

Common Questions
What is the DPEA screening direction on the Edinburgh data centre appeal?
On 30 July 2026 the Planning and Environmental Appeals Division overturned Edinburgh Council's screening opinion, ruling a full environmental impact assessment is required before the appeal can be decided.Source: DPEA
Why did Edinburgh Council refuse the South Gyle data centre?
Edinburgh Council refused planning permission in principle on 9 February 2026 for a 212.42 MW data centre proposed for the former RBS headquarters at South Gyle.Source: DPEA case file
What is Edinburgh Council's role in local planning?
It is the local planning authority for the City of Edinburgh.Source: https://www.dpea.scotland.gov.uk/CaseDetails.aspx?ID=128582
Source Material

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Updated 22 October 2026. Editorial standards.