Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
US Midterms 2026
1OCT

Judge Ali voids FEMA election conditions

3 min read
15:11UTC

Judge Amir Ali struck down FEMA's rule tying a fifth of states' counterterrorism grants to SAVE checks, ballot audits and a move off voting machines.

PoliticsDeveloping
Key takeaway

States may use DHS's SAVE System, but FEMA cannot withhold counterterrorism grants to force it.

Amir Ali, a US district judge for the District of Columbia, on 28 September vacated election conditions that FEMA (the Federal Emergency Management Agency) had attached to Homeland Security Grant Program counterterrorism funds⁠1. Nashville, four Texas counties (Harris, Travis, Dallas and El Paso) and Columbus, Ohio, brought the case, Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County v. Department of Homeland Security, in August.

The conditions required states and high-risk cities to use SAVE (the database DHS uses to check immigration and citizenship status), which DHS (America's Department of Homeland Security) runs for state and federal agencies, run a 5% manual audit of paper ballots and move away from voting machines, on pain of losing 20% of each state's allocation⁠2. Ali wrote that the statute lets FEMA fund projects that states propose but does not let it "use the possibility of grants to induce states or high-risk urban areas to carry out the federal government's preferred projects at their own expense."

The ruling came three days after the Supreme Court let DHS restore the expanded SAVE System, which lower courts had blocked since June. Together the two decisions separate the tool from the lever. States may use the expanded SAVE, but DHS cannot make their counterterrorism money depend on it, so take-up before 3 November rests on each state's own choice.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

FEMA, the Federal Emergency Management Agency, hands out grants to help states and cities prepare for terrorism and disasters. This year it added conditions about elections. To get their full grant, states had to use DHS's SAVE System to check voters' citizenship, count 5% of paper ballots by hand and move away from voting machines. If they refused, they would lose 20% of the money. A federal judge in Washington, DC, said FEMA had no power to attach those conditions, because the grant law only lets it fund projects that states and cities propose themselves.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

The federal government has little direct power over how states run elections. Article I gives states the first say on the manner of congressional elections, and Congress has never passed a national rule on voting machines or audits.

Since 2025 the administration has used grant conditions as the workaround. Homeland Security Grant Program money reaches every state and large city, so a 20% penalty gives Washington leverage without a new law. The suit, brought by Nashville, Columbus and four Texas counties, tested whether FEMA's statute allows that leverage.

Escalation

Contained for now. The conditions are vacated, so states face no grant penalty before 3 November. DHS can appeal to the D.C. Circuit.

What could happen next?
  • Consequence

    States and cities keep full Homeland Security Grant Program allocations without changing election equipment or audits before 3 November.

  • Precedent

    A statutory ruling against grant conditions on election administration narrows one route the federal government has to shape how states run elections.

First Reported In

Update #19 · Bulk voter citizenship checks are back

Brennan Center for Justice· 1 Oct 2026
Read original →
Different Perspectives
University of Florida Election Lab
University of Florida Election Lab
The lab, run by Michael McDonald, estimates about 124.3 million ballots, a raw midterm record, and turnout of about 49.4% of eligible voters, second to 2018's 50.05%. The raw record reflects population growth more than a record rate, so the late count is working through a near-2018 electorate.
Thune's critics on the right, including Senator Ron Johnson
Thune's critics on the right, including Senator Ron Johnson
Ron Johnson backed the failed 31-15 motion to delay Thune's re-election, after activists such as Mike Cernovich blamed the leader for the defeat. Their complaint is that Republicans could have passed the SAVE Act; in January it meets a Democratic Senate instead.
Senator John Thune
Senator John Thune
Thune was re-elected Senate Republican leader by acclamation on 10 November after a motion to delay failed 31-15. He kept the filibuster that stopped the SAVE Act, the choice his critics on the right blame for the defeat.
House Republicans under Jim Jordan
House Republicans under Jim Jordan
House Republicans elected Jordan minority leader by 106 votes to 73 over Steve Scalise on 10 November, after Speaker Mike Johnson declined to run. They replaced the leadership that lost the majority, while Senate Republicans kept theirs.
Donald Trump
Donald Trump
Trump asked on Truth Social on 9 November whether anybody believed the election "was honest" and blamed the machines, having told The New York Times on polling night he would accept the results. No Republican campaign had sued over a 2026 result by 10 November, so the claim has no case behind it.
Judge David O. Carter
Judge David O. Carter
Carter closed the Justice Department's suit over about 20,000 California mail ballots on 10 November after the department withdrew it, writing that the suit "attempted to disrupt an ongoing election". The closure leaves the department with no court order touching a 2026 California ballot.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.