Skip to content
You can now search across every topic, entity and event.What's new
UK Local Elections 2026
22MAY

Findlay co-opts his Scottish Tory rivals

3 min read
10:09UTC

Russell Findlay survived post-election leadership pressure by giving frontbench posts to Murdo Fraser and Meghan Gallacher; the Scottish Conservatives finished on 12 Holyrood seats, their smallest result since 1999, ceding official opposition to Scottish Labour on 17.

PoliticsDeveloping
Key takeaway

Findlay's co-option absorbs the challenge without a vote; the summer conference is the next institutional test.

Russell Findlay survived the immediate post-election leadership pressure on the Scottish Conservatives by giving frontbench posts to both his potential rivals. Murdo Fraser took Business, Economy, Tourism and Culture; Meghan Gallacher took Housing; Sandesh Gulhane kept the Health spokesperson role he already held . All Scottish Conservative Westminster MPs publicly backed him within hours of the appointments.

The Scottish Conservatives finished on 12 Holyrood seats, 9.3% of the chamber and the smallest result since devolution in 1999 . Scottish Labour on 17 takes the official opposition role and the financial allowances that follow. Co-option is the classical procedural answer to a leadership challenge without a public mandate: bring the potential rival inside the tent before they can build the case for a vote. Gulhane declined to rule out Findlay being ousted on 8 May but did not trigger a contest. Bringing Fraser and Gallacher onto the frontbench means a contested vote would have to come from a fourth source the public has not yet heard from.

The arrangement holds until the summer Scottish Conservative conference, the institutional venue where a contest would need to be either tabled or formally deferred. Reform UK on 17 seats ties Scottish Labour on raw numbers and represents 13% of the chamber but sits outside the official opposition convention. Holyrood's post-7-May opposition runs through Anas Sarwar, not through Findlay. The Scottish Conservatives' route back to the official opposition would require either a Reform implosion at Holyrood or a Labour collapse, neither of which the seat arithmetic currently supports.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Scotland's Conservative Party had its worst result at Holyrood since devolution began in 1999, winning only 12 seats. Their leader, Russell Findlay, came under immediate pressure to resign. He survived by giving the two politicians most likely to challenge him, Murdo Fraser and Meghan Gallacher, jobs in his opposition team. This is a classic political manoeuvre: bring potential rivals inside the tent so they do not have an external platform to build a case against you. The Scottish Conservatives are now the fourth-largest party in Holyrood, behind the SNP, Scottish Labour, and Reform UK Scotland. Scottish Labour, with 17 seats, is now the official opposition, which means it gets more resources and leads parliamentary debates. The next test for Findlay is the Scottish Conservative summer conference, where a formal leadership challenge could be raised.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

The Scottish Conservative collapse from the 2017 peak of 31 seats to 12 in 2026 traces three interlocking structural causes. First, Ruth Davidson's departure in 2019 removed the party's distinctive Scottish brand and left it dependent on UK Conservative electoral performance for Scottish momentum, which became a liability through the Partygate and Truss cycles.

Second, Reform UK Scotland's arrival at 17 Holyrood seats in 2026 specifically ate into the unionist and social-conservative vote that formed the Scottish Tory core since devolution. Third, Scottish Labour's recovery to 17 seats under Anas Sarwar took the centre-right unionist tactical vote that had previously parked with Davidson's Tories to keep the SNP out of a majority.

Findlay inherited all three structural disadvantages simultaneously. His immediate problem is not the leadership challenge, which co-option has absorbed; it is the 9.3% chamber position that has reduced the Scottish Conservatives to a fourth or fifth force rather than the credible official opposition they were under Davidson.

What could happen next?
  • Risk

    Fraser's appointment to a lesser portfolio than he previously shadowed gives him limited institutional reason to maintain loyalty to Findlay if poll ratings do not improve before the summer conference.

    Short term · Assessed
  • Consequence

    Losing official opposition status means Scottish Labour's Anas Sarwar chairs the relevant Holyrood committees and receives additional parliamentary funding, shifting the Scottish parliamentary agenda away from Scottish Conservative priorities for this parliament.

    Immediate · Reported
  • Precedent

    A Scottish Conservative party at 9.3% of the chamber for a full parliamentary cycle would be the weakest devolved Conservative performance in any of the four UK nations, with implications for its funding formula allocation from party headquarters.

    Long term · Assessed
First Reported In

Update #9 · Three constitutional contests open

STV News· 22 May 2026
Read original
Different Perspectives
Local Government Association
Local Government Association
New chair Eamonn O'Brien broke the LGA's neutrality on reorganisation for the first time since December 2024, telling the incoming prime minister the 'unprecedented scale' of disaggregation risks statutory services and asking him to adjust the LGR timetable, aligning the sector's institutional voice with the judicial review claims Suffolk, Essex and Norfolk have already filed.
Reform UK
Reform UK
Reform's £12m Harborne windfall from 2025 predates the 25 March retrospective crypto-donation ban, so the new law does not reach it; a live police probe into £500,000 of Cottrell donations continues, while the standards inquiry into Harborne's undeclared £5m gift is frozen since Farage vacated Clacton on 8 July.
Incoming Burnham government
Incoming Burnham government
Burnham secured 349 of the backing the NEC's 81-MP threshold required by 13 July, becoming Labour leader on 17 July and prime minister on 20 July without a members' ballot. He now inherits the LGR timetable the LGA wants him to adjust and a finance bill his own backbencher, Liam Byrne, is trying to harden further via amendment NC34.
Rupert Lowe / Restore Britain
Rupert Lowe / Restore Britain
Lowe called Farage's Clacton contest a 'Reform-sponsored media circus' and kept Restore Britain out of it, pledging instead to stand in the second by-election he expects the Harborne inquiry to force later this year. The boycott doubles as a signal that Restore Britain, not Reform, will contest the 'real' vote.
Kemi Badenoch / Conservative Party
Kemi Badenoch / Conservative Party
Badenoch dismissed Farage's Clacton contest as a 'fake by-election' and joined the boycott, but reserved the right to fight a genuine second contest if Greenberg's inquiry forces one. The Conservatives are betting their real fight comes in autumn, not July.
Rhun ap Iorwerth / Plaid Cymru
Rhun ap Iorwerth / Plaid Cymru
Ap Iorwerth defended a £145m NHS allocation at First Minister's Questions on 1 July, blaming a graduate-nurse shortfall on 2022 training decisions taken before his Plaid-led government took office in May. Answering for choices his government did not make gives his new administration its first real accountability test.