Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Data Centres: Boom and Backlash
15NOV

Texas developer sues county over pause

4 min read
23:07UTC

RCM Hill LLC sued Hill County, Texas on 28 May for $100m, arguing the moratorium on its 1,235 MW Project Aquila campus is an unconstitutional regulatory taking.

IndustryDeveloping
Key takeaway

RCM Hill's suit is the first Fifth Amendment taking claim against a US data-centre moratorium.

RCM Hill LLC sued Hill County, Texas on 28 May 2026, asking for $100m in damages and arguing the county had no power to halt its Project Aquila data centre, a 1,235 MW campus planned across 800 acres⁠1. The developer says it signed four landowner contracts worth more than $80m over 16 months, and faces a 24 July ERCOT deadline requiring a $61.75m deposit to hold its grid slot.

Every prior backlash story ran one way: a community blocks a build. This one runs the other. The complaint, as reported by KWTX and KXXV, invokes regulatory taking under the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments and the Texas Constitution, the principle that government cannot strip the economic use of private property without paying for it. It quotes the county's own 12 May meeting back at it. County Judge Shane Brassell called the moratorium "illegal"; county attorney David Holmes warned commissioners they lacked the authority. They passed it 3-2 regardless, then tabled the suit.

Texas counties hold weaker police powers than its cities, which is why service blocks in Ohio and Michigan stuck and Maine's statewide freeze cleared its legislature, while a county pause now faces a constitutional test. A construction ban on a contracted, deposit-backed 1,235 MW site is a far stronger taking claim than a routine zoning limit, because the developer can show concrete investment-backed expectations the moratorium destroyed.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

In most of the US, a local government can restrict what gets built in its area. But in Texas, counties and cities have different legal powers. Texas cities can zone land; Texas counties generally cannot, unless the state has given them specific authority to do so. Hill County voted to pause a massive data-centre project called Project Aquila. The developer, RCM Hill LLC, is now suing the county for $100 million, arguing the county never had the legal power to stop it in the first place. The county's own judge and lawyer said the moratorium looked unlawful before the vote. The three commissioners voted for it anyway. There is also a financial deadline: the developer must pay a $61.75 million deposit to ERCOT by 24 July 2026 to keep its grid connection slot. A moratorium that runs past that date wipes out the slot, which took over a year of queue work to secure.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Texas counties derive their land-use authority from a fragmented set of enabling statutes rather than a general zoning power. The Texas Government Code grants limited extraterritorial jurisdiction powers to municipalities but gives counties far narrower tools, primarily nuisance abatement and some subdivision rules.

A commissioner's court moratorium on a specific land use has no clear statutory basis unless the legislature has authorised it. The county attorney's pre-vote warning tracked exactly this gap.

The financial urgency in the case, the 24 July ERCOT deadline requiring a $61.75m deposit, is itself a structural artefact of ERCOT's queue reform. ERCOT imposed binding deposit deadlines to force speculative applicants to either commit capital or exit the queue.

That reform, designed to clean the book, now gives a developer a hard countdown that a moratorium can destroy, creating a class of taking claim where the regulatory action imposes a concrete financial deadline loss rather than a vague future reduction in value.

What could happen next?
  • Precedent

    A developer win, whether on ultra vires or taking grounds, would discourage other Texas counties from imposing moratoriums without clear statutory authority, reshaping the geography of moratorium activity toward stronger-authority jurisdictions like cities and states.

    Medium term · Assessed
  • Risk

    If the Hill County case proceeds to a damages phase and the county cannot pay, it creates a fiscal crisis for a small rural government, potentially chilling elected officials in similar jurisdictions from voting their constituents' wishes on land-use questions.

    Medium term · Suggested
  • Consequence

    Developer strategy in moratorium-threatened jurisdictions shifts: commit capital to ERCOT deposits early to establish investment-backed expectations evidence, strengthen any future taking claim while simultaneously creating a financial hostage to the moratorium's duration.

    Short term · Suggested
First Reported In

Update #5 · Who pays when the grid bends for AI

KWTX· 2 Jun 2026
Read original →
Different Perspectives
Mooresville Board of Commissioners
Mooresville Board of Commissioners
The town board north of Charlotte voted unanimously on 2 November to stop taking data-centre applications for 12 months. Commissioners cited environmental and electrical impacts, joining other North Carolina towns that have paused new projects.
Naver
Naver
Naver signed a US$9bn contract under which a Brookfield vehicle owns the GPUs and buildings and sells computing to Naver Cloud. It guarantees the fees for up to eight years, which also unlocked Nvidia's US$1bn equity investment.
Saudi Aramco
Saudi Aramco
Aramco closed its purchase of 49% of HUMAIN on 1 November, paying about US$2.6bn in cash and adding its own AI, compute and digital assets. Chief executive Amin Nasser cast the deal as a gain in technology standing.
NEXTDC board
NEXTDC board
The board called the Goodman and Digital Realty stake opportunistic and said it had received no takeover proposal. It enters the 20 November meeting with a new chairman search, a 10% fee cut and a spill resolution on the agenda.
Brasscom
Brasscom
Sergio Sgobbi of Brazil's technology industry association says investors face uncertainty until the Redata rules are public. Members need rulings on gas and the CDE levy after Lula said data centres must build their own power.
Johari Abdul Ghani, Malaysia's investment, trade and industry minister
Johari Abdul Ghani, Malaysia's investment, trade and industry minister
He told the Dewan Rakyat in October that data centres pay for all the grid capacity they reserve and fund upgrades to TNB's network. Google's 4 November pledge repeats those terms as its own.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.