Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Data Centres: Boom and Backlash
15NOV

Hill County folds, lawsuit lives on

3 min read
23:07UTC

Hill County, Texas rescinded its data-centre moratorium on Thursday 4 June, seven days after developer RCM Hill sued it for $100 million. The suit is still live.

IndustryDeveloping
Key takeaway

A $100m taking suit reversed a Texas data-centre ban in a week, before any judge ruled on it.

Hill County, Texas voted unanimously on Thursday 4 June to rescind its moratorium on data-centre development, not because a court ordered it but to cap taxpayer liability. The county had blocked RCM Hill LLC's 1,235 MW Project Aquila campus near Hillsboro; on Thursday 28 May the developer sued for $100 million, calling the freeze an unconstitutional taking of property. Seven days later the county folded.⁠1

Rescinding the moratorium did not end the litigation. RCM Hill still seeks a court declaration that the original freeze was unlawful, plus damages dated from the day it passed. That keeps the Fifth Amendment taking question alive even with no moratorium left to challenge. The Fifth Amendment bars government from taking private property without compensation, and developers are now testing whether a building freeze counts as exactly that. A ruling for RCM Hill would chill every other county weighing a ban.

The county did not abandon oversight altogether. It replaced the moratorium with disclosure rules: applicants must now declare water use, traffic, noise and economic effect, and notify the public more widely than before.

Three moratoriums have now fallen by three different routes. Maine's first-in-nation statewide ban fell to a governor's veto; Prince William County's fast-track rezoning fell to an appellate court; Hill County fell to a single lawyer's letter. Each consent tool has met a sharper instrument of restraint, and developers have learned that the threat of a ruling can work faster than the ruling itself.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Hill County in rural Texas voted to block all new data-centre construction in 2026. A developer called RCM Hill had been planning a giant computer campus there, called Project Aquila, that would have used as much electricity as a city of roughly 900,000 homes. The county freeze stopped all construction. Seven days after RCM Hill sued the county for $100 million, claiming the freeze illegally took away its property rights under the US Constitution, the county reversed course and voted unanimously to lift the ban. The lawsuit is still alive: RCM Hill still wants compensation for the time its project was blocked. The case shows that a rural county with a small budget faces a very unequal legal fight when it tries to stop a billion-dollar data-centre project without a clear legal basis for doing so.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Hill County's original moratorium reflected a common pattern in rural Texas counties: a large-scale industrial project arrives with insufficient advance engagement, local officials face constituent pressure and respond with a blanket freeze rather than a structured review process. The county had no pre-existing land-use framework for facilities drawing more than 200 MW, so the moratorium was the default response in the absence of a permitting mechanism.

Project Aquila at 1,235 MW would have drawn roughly 1.5% of ERCOT's peak demand from a single rural county, an impact scale that requires a genuine public-interest analysis rather than a blanket halt.

RCM Hill's $100 million lawsuit converts the county's failure to design a permitting process into a direct fiscal liability, which is why the rescission came before any court hearing: the county's legal counsel almost certainly calculated that defending the moratorium in federal court was more expensive than permitting the project.

What could happen next?
  • Precedent

    RCM Hill's pre-adjudication reversal establishes that a federal taking lawsuit is sufficient deterrent to force rescission without a court ruling, lowering the bar for other developers facing rural moratoriums.

    Short term · Assessed
  • Risk

    Rural counties across Texas and other ERCOT states with no large-load permitting frameworks face the same asymmetric litigation exposure if they impose blanket moratoriums rather than structured review processes.

    Medium term · Assessed
  • Consequence

    The active damages claim creates an unresolved legal question on the quantum of loss for data-centre downtime, which could establish a precedent figure that all future taking claims cite.

    Medium term · Reported
First Reported In

Update #6 · Oregon bills data centres, not homes

Texas Tribune· 10 Jun 2026
Read original →
Causes and effects
This Event
Hill County folds, lawsuit lives on
A developer reversed a county ban using the threat of a constitutional ruling rather than a ruling itself, a faster lever than any electoral or appellate route.
Different Perspectives
Mooresville Board of Commissioners
Mooresville Board of Commissioners
The town board north of Charlotte voted unanimously on 2 November to stop taking data-centre applications for 12 months. Commissioners cited environmental and electrical impacts, joining other North Carolina towns that have paused new projects.
Naver
Naver
Naver signed a US$9bn contract under which a Brookfield vehicle owns the GPUs and buildings and sells computing to Naver Cloud. It guarantees the fees for up to eight years, which also unlocked Nvidia's US$1bn equity investment.
Saudi Aramco
Saudi Aramco
Aramco closed its purchase of 49% of HUMAIN on 1 November, paying about US$2.6bn in cash and adding its own AI, compute and digital assets. Chief executive Amin Nasser cast the deal as a gain in technology standing.
NEXTDC board
NEXTDC board
The board called the Goodman and Digital Realty stake opportunistic and said it had received no takeover proposal. It enters the 20 November meeting with a new chairman search, a 10% fee cut and a spill resolution on the agenda.
Brasscom
Brasscom
Sergio Sgobbi of Brazil's technology industry association says investors face uncertainty until the Redata rules are public. Members need rulings on gas and the CDE levy after Lula said data centres must build their own power.
Johari Abdul Ghani, Malaysia's investment, trade and industry minister
Johari Abdul Ghani, Malaysia's investment, trade and industry minister
He told the Dewan Rakyat in October that data centres pay for all the grid capacity they reserve and fund upgrades to TNB's network. Google's 4 November pledge repeats those terms as its own.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.