Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Data Centres: Boom and Backlash
15NOV

Lula: data centres must build own power

3 min read
23:07UTC

Lula told Brazil's energy council that data centres will not run on the people's electricity. His ministries are still split over gas and a levy on power bills.

IndustryDeveloping
Key takeaway

Brazil's data-centre rules could shift a power-bill levy onto households, against Lula's own stated line.

"It will not be the people's energy that is used for data centres," Lula told Brazil's National Energy Policy Council (CNPE) on Friday 6 November, according to the Brazilian outlets O Liberal and TMC⁠1. Whoever invests in data centres, he said, must "build their own energy".

His ministries have not agreed what that means. The decree that puts the Redata tax regime, a tax break for data-centre investment, into effect under the law Lula signed in September had not been published by 9 November. According to TMC, the mines and energy ministry backs counting natural gas with carbon compensation; the finance ministry first blocked gas and now accepts it with conditions; renewable generators say gas fails the low-emission benchmark.

The sharper fight is over the Conta de Desenvolvimento Energético (CDE), the levy on power bills that funds Brazil's energy subsidies. If data centres are classed as self-producers (companies treated as generating their own power), they stop paying it, which would leave other consumers covering their share, the opposite of Lula's line. "Until the rules are public, everything is uncertain," said Sergio Sgobbi of Brasscom, the technology industry association.

Miriam Belchior, minister of the Casa Civil (the president's chief-of-staff office), said the rules were in their final stage and would come after Lula's COP31 trip; Portal Energia Limpa puts the announcement in the week of 16 November⁠2.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Brazil passed a law in September offering tax breaks, under a scheme called Redata, to companies that build data centres, the warehouses of computers behind online services and AI. The detailed rules still have to come in a government decree. President Lula said data-centre investors must supply their own electricity, so that ordinary people's power is not diverted to them. Government ministries disagree on two points: whether gas power stations count as clean enough, and whether data centres that produce their own power should stop paying a charge on electricity bills that funds subsidies such as cheaper power for poorer families.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Brazil's cheapest renewable power sits in the north-east, far from the São Paulo region where most data-centre demand lies. Transmission access is now scarce enough that the grid operator ran its first competitive allocation in October.

Brazilian power bills carry a charge that funds the Conta de Desenvolvimento Energético. Any user that leaves it shifts its share onto everyone else, which makes the self-producer question a fight over household tariffs.

The Senate wrote 'renewable or low-emission' into the law without defining the threshold, leaving ministries to settle gas in a decree.

Escalation

Unresolved. The president has set a public line that his ministries now have to turn into rules. Casa Civil's planned announcement after COP31 will show which side won.

What could happen next?
  • Consequence

    Investors in Brazilian data centres face uncertain power costs until the decree is out.

    Immediate · Assessed
  • Risk

    A CDE exemption for self-producers would raise other consumers' bills, contrary to Lula's stated aim.

    Medium term · Suggested
  • Opportunity

    A strict low-emission test would channel data-centre demand into new wind, solar and storage projects.

    Long term · Suggested
First Reported In

Update #18 · Norway shuts its grid queue to data centres

TMC· 15 Nov 2026
Read original →
Causes and effects
This Event
Lula: data centres must build own power
How Brazil classes data centres under its Redata tax regime will decide whether other electricity users pay part of their share of energy subsidies.
Different Perspectives
Mooresville Board of Commissioners
Mooresville Board of Commissioners
The town board north of Charlotte voted unanimously on 2 November to stop taking data-centre applications for 12 months. Commissioners cited environmental and electrical impacts, joining other North Carolina towns that have paused new projects.
Naver
Naver
Naver signed a US$9bn contract under which a Brookfield vehicle owns the GPUs and buildings and sells computing to Naver Cloud. It guarantees the fees for up to eight years, which also unlocked Nvidia's US$1bn equity investment.
Saudi Aramco
Saudi Aramco
Aramco closed its purchase of 49% of HUMAIN on 1 November, paying about US$2.6bn in cash and adding its own AI, compute and digital assets. Chief executive Amin Nasser cast the deal as a gain in technology standing.
NEXTDC board
NEXTDC board
The board called the Goodman and Digital Realty stake opportunistic and said it had received no takeover proposal. It enters the 20 November meeting with a new chairman search, a 10% fee cut and a spill resolution on the agenda.
Brasscom
Brasscom
Sergio Sgobbi of Brazil's technology industry association says investors face uncertainty until the Redata rules are public. Members need rulings on gas and the CDE levy after Lula said data centres must build their own power.
Johari Abdul Ghani, Malaysia's investment, trade and industry minister
Johari Abdul Ghani, Malaysia's investment, trade and industry minister
He told the Dewan Rakyat in October that data centres pay for all the grid capacity they reserve and fund upgrades to TNB's network. Google's 4 November pledge repeats those terms as its own.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.