Skip to content
Briefings are running a touch slower this week while we rebuild the foundations.See roadmap
AI: Jobs, Power & Money
24MAY

Rival studies split on AI's hit to jobs

2 min read
15:19UTC

A New York Fed study finds little sign AI is cutting hiring, and says the decline in exposed roles started before ChatGPT shipped. It lands 30 days after Stanford put the figure at 34 prevented hires per layoff. Colorado guts its AI employment law as Cisco and Intuit cut thousands on record revenue.

Key takeaway

Both the evidence for AI-jobs intervention and the laws to act on it retreated in the same fortnight.

This briefing mapped
Loading map…
Economic
Regulatory
Domestic

The New York Fed found minimal sign AI is cutting hiring and said the decline in exposed roles began before ChatGPT shipped, 30 days after Stanford put the figure at 34 prevented hires per declared layoff.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

The New York Fed published a job-postings study on 14 May finding little sign AI has cut hiring since ChatGPT launched. The decline in exposed roles began before December 2022.

This contradicts Stanford's April finding that AI blocks roughly one million US hires a year. Two credible institutions now read the same labour market in opposite directions. 

Colorado replaced the most advanced US state AI employment statute with a notice-only shell after a federal court stayed it and the DOJ joined Elon Musk's xAI in challenging it as unconstitutional.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Colorado's governor signed SB 26-189 in mid-May, replacing the strongest US state AI hiring law with a notice-only Shell. A federal judge had stayed the original on 27 April.

The Justice Department joined Elon Musk's xAI in the challenge. The EU softened its own employer AI duty the same fortnight. 

Cisco cut roughly 4,000 staff the same day it reported record $15.8bn revenue, lifting its AI-infrastructure order target to about $9bn and making a fifth straight week of record-revenue firms cutting deep.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Cisco cut about 4,000 staff on 14 May, the day it posted a record $15.8 billion quarter. Chief executive Chuck Robbins lifted The Firm's AI hardware order target to roughly $9 billion.

CBOE and Cloudflare ran the same pattern that fortnight. A record quarter has become the trigger for cuts, not protection against them. 

Intuit cut 17% of staff and, in the same announcement, agreed to feed its tax and finance data into Anthropic and OpenAI, turning displaced workers' expertise into training signal for their replacement.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Intuit cut about 3,000 staff, 17% of its workforce, on 20 May, citing an AI refocus across TurboTax and QuickBooks. The same day it signed data deals with Anthropic and OpenAI.

The workers being replaced are handing their expertise to the systems taking their jobs. Each round widens the model-makers' data lead. 

Sources:NASSCOM

NASSCOM named JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs and Apple among firms expanding in-house India offices even as they cut at home, a relocation channel no US AI disclosure law or federal dataset can see.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

India's IT industry body reported the sector added about 140,000 jobs in 2026 to reach 5.9 million, with JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs and Apple expanding in-house offshore centres. Entry-level hiring fell 20 to 25%.

Jobs moved from New York to Bengaluru trigger no US layoff filing and never enter Stanford's hiring data. 

The Directors Guild opened AMPTP contract talks on 12 May with AI training-use protection central, the next test of whether a Hollywood union can beat the limited terms the writers and actors settled for.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

The Directors Guild opened studio talks on 12 May, with protection against AI training on directors' work a central demand. It follows the actors' union deal, which won likeness consent but no AI royalty.

President Christopher Nolan also wants higher healthcare contributions. The talks test whether any Hollywood union can beat the no-royalty precedent. 

Sources:Boston.com

The ONS reported UK payrolled employment down 210,000 year on year, more than double the prior month's reading, with vacancies at a four-year low and real pay growth at 0.1%, and no AI breakdown at all.

The UK Office for National Statistics reported on 19 May that payrolled jobs fell 210,000 over the year to April, more than double the prior month's drop. Vacancies hit 705,000, a five-year low.

Real pay growth was near flat at 0.1%. The agency published no breakdown of how much AI drove the fall. 

The EU Digital Omnibus still needs formal Council and Parliament votes before an August adoption target, the last step that would lock in a softened worker-facing rule, or reopen it if the timetable slips.

Sources profile:This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

The EU Digital Omnibus still awaited formal Council and Parliament votes in late May. A 7 May deal had weakened the employer duty to ensure workers understand AI systems.

Brussels targets August for adoption. Until the votes pass, the softened text carries no enforceable obligation on employers. 

Closing comments

The displacement count is going up; the protection floor is going down. The specific mechanism that determines how far the gap widens is the DOJ constitutional doctrine: if it holds and is successfully cited in challenges to a second state AI employment law before the midterms, the preemption template becomes self-reinforcing and the Warner-Rounds study commission is the realistic ceiling for federal action through at least late 2027. The named decision point is whether the Supreme Court accepts a certiorari petition on the Colorado dormant Commerce Clause ruling, which would require the courts to decide whether states can regulate AI employment at all. Without cert, state-level protection is functionally defeated and the federal measurement gap continues unsupported by any enforcement mechanism.

Different Perspectives
US federal executive (DOJ, xAI)
US federal executive (DOJ, xAI)
The DOJ joined xAI's constitutional challenge to Colorado's AI Act, converting a private legal theory into federal executive doctrine opposing state-level AI employment protection. Every other state legislature considering similar laws now has a worked template for how the executive will respond.
European Parliament and Council (Digital Omnibus)
European Parliament and Council (Digital Omnibus)
The Digital Omnibus trilogue concession on AI-literacy duties reflects the Draghi report's argument that compliance overhead suppresses EU AI adoption. The Council traded the binding literacy mechanism for employer flexibility, leaving the December 2027 high-risk employment deadline without the worker-facing transparency layer Parliament had built around it.
India's IT sector workforce and NASSCOM
India's IT sector workforce and NASSCOM
NASSCOM's FY2026 data shows India's sector at 5.9 million while entry-level hiring fell 20 to 25%. GCC expansion by JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs and Apple benefits mid-career workers while closing the graduate entry pathway, replicating the under-25 displacement the NY Fed documented in US AI-exposed occupations.
UK workers and Bank of England
UK workers and Bank of England
The ONS May 2026 bulletin showed payrolled employment down 210,000 year on year with no AI-specific breakdown, while the Bank of England's stress scenario used 500,000 additional unemployed as its AI-displacement worst case. UK workers are approaching that threshold through a dataset that cannot name its own cause.
Chinese Ministry of Human Resources (MOHRSS)
Chinese Ministry of Human Resources (MOHRSS)
China's MOHRSS recognised 42 new AI occupations in April 2026 while Hangzhou courts upheld bans on AI-driven dismissal without retraining under the Labour Contract Law. Beijing's regulatory posture contrasts directly with Colorado's retreat: Chinese courts are adding employment liability for AI-driven redundancy while US courts remove state-level AI worker protection.
German IG Metall and European trade unions
German IG Metall and European trade unions
German unions led by IG Metall have pushed for binding co-determination rights on AI deployment since 2024; the Digital Omnibus literacy-duty weakening directly undercuts their model, which depends on a statutory information floor before works councils can challenge AI systems affecting members.