Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Autonomous Systems: Land & Sea
24JUN

Trilateral loses venue, keeps deadlock

3 min read
16:13UTC

The third US-Russia-Ukraine trilateral cannot meet in Abu Dhabi and may relocate to Istanbul, but the harder problem — Russia's demand that Ukraine cede four oblasts before talks continue — has not moved.

TechnologyDeveloping
Key takeaway

Istanbul hosted a near-deal in 2022 that collapsed; its symbolic freight complicates its neutrality as a venue.

The third round of US-Russia-Ukraine trilateral negotiations, scheduled for 5–6 March, cannot proceed in Abu Dhabi because of the wider Middle East conflict. President Zelenskyy confirmed on 2 March that the talks are not cancelled — only the venue is unresolved⁠1. Bloomberg sources identified Istanbul as the front-runner replacement⁠2, and Turkey's Anadolu Agency separately reported that Russia confirmed the city⁠3. No final announcement had been made as of 5 March.

The venue disruption matters less than what awaits any table they sit around. Russia's precondition — that Ukraine formally cede Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson before talks continue — remains on the table. Moscow has issued structurally similar ultimatums before every round since 2022 and attended regardless, a pattern that suggests the demand functions as a negotiating anchor rather than a genuine walk-away trigger. The second Abu Dhabi round in February achieved technical progress on ceasefire monitoring mechanics but deadlocked on territory, security guarantees, and the composition of any monitoring force. None of those positions have shifted.

Three constraints define the negotiating space regardless of city. Trump told Zelenskyy on 25 February he wanted the war ended "in a month"; Russia's stated position remains "no deadlines." The trilateral format excludes all 27 EU member states despite Europe having funded more of Ukraine's war effort than the United States — a gap Germany's chancellor addressed directly in Washington on 3 March. And the substantive deadlock is circular: Ukraine will not concede territory in advance, Russia will not negotiate without that concession, and Washington has not indicated which side's position it considers more negotiable.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Peace talks between the US, Russia, and Ukraine were due in Abu Dhabi but had to move because of unrelated Middle East tensions. Istanbul is the replacement. Turkey has maintained relationships with both sides throughout the war — selling weapons to Ukraine while buying gas from Russia — which makes it acceptable to both parties as a host. The venue matters less than the substance. Russia still insists Ukraine formally hand over four regions before talks can proceed. Crucially, Ukraine's constitution prohibits surrendering territory without a national referendum — a legal barrier that no Ukrainian president can waive by executive decision, regardless of US pressure. Russia has made similar demands before every previous round and attended anyway, which suggests the precondition serves a domestic audience rather than being a genuine deal-breaker.

Deep Analysis
Synthesis

Ukraine's constitution (Article 157) bars altering state territory without a national referendum — a legal constraint Zelensky cannot waive by executive decision regardless of pressure from Washington. Russia's four-oblast precondition is therefore structurally incompatible with Ukrainian constitutional law, not merely with Ukrainian political will. This suggests the precondition functions as a procedural legitimisation device for Russian domestic audiences rather than a genuine negotiating position — which would explain why Russia consistently attends talks regardless of unmet demands.

What could happen next?
  • Risk

    Venue uncertainty delaying the 5–6 March meeting risks dissipating technical momentum from the second round's progress on ceasefire monitoring.

    Immediate · Assessed
  • Consequence

    A framework agreed before European observer status is secured gives Merz's implementation veto immediate practical teeth, creating post-agreement deadlock between the US-brokered text and European non-endorsement.

    Short term · Assessed
  • Precedent

    A deal concluded in trilateral format without European participation sets a structural template for US-Russia bilateralism that excludes EU institutional role in European security architecture.

    Medium term · Assessed
First Reported In

Update #2 · Shadow fleet tanker sunk, talks seek venue

Ukrainska Pravda· 5 Mar 2026
Read original →
Different Perspectives
EDGE Group
EDGE Group
EDGE took control of Italian engine maker CMD in October and signed exploratory USV memorandums with Novamarine and Abu Dhabi Ship Building in early November. It is assembling an Italian hull and engine supply chain around Emirati autonomy, with no customer named.
Japan Ministry of Defense
Japan Ministry of Defense
Nikkei reported on 29 October that the ministry will start research in fiscal 2027 towards mass-producing underwater drones for detection and attack, with prototypes by fiscal 2035. The stated aim is to deter China's growing submarine fleet with fewer sailors at risk.
Kongsberg Discovery
Kongsberg Discovery
Kongsberg received a $54m DIU modification, mainly for AUV deliveries, and Camilla Kiss said the unit has signed 1.7bn Norwegian kroner of AUV contracts in 2026. The Norwegian maker sells into the US market as an established production line.
Elbit Systems
Elbit Systems
Elbit bought ISE of Vancouver, maker of more than 250 AUVs, on 20 October for a price it called not material. The Israeli group adds an underwater vehicle line to its naval business.
Defense Acquisition Program Administration
Defense Acquisition Program Administration
DAPA's 179th committee cleared a 591bn won mine-warfare USV programme on 6 November, alongside the Jangbogo-N nuclear submarine. HD Hyundai's Long Beach trial with Anduril shows Korean industry pitching hulls abroad while Seoul funds its own.
Finland National Emergency Supply Agency
Finland National Emergency Supply Agency
NESA opened an €11m competition on 4 November for radiation-sensing drones and ground robots, including quadrupeds, for the EU's rescEU stockpile. It is a civil-protection buyer using open tender, with a decision expected in March 2027.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.