3AUG

SBU officer Khmara takes defence duties

2 min read

10:16UTC

Zelenskyy assigned Yevhen Khmara, acting head of the SBU, to perform the Defence Minister's duties on 16 July, after Interior Minister Ihor Klymenko turned the job down.

← Back to Russia's costliest month, smallest gain Jump to analysis ↓

ConflictDeveloping

Key takeaway

Khmara's strike record answers none of the recruitment questions that cost his predecessor the job.

Volodymyr Zelenskyy assigned Yevhen Khmara to perform the Defence Minister's duties on 16 July, pending a confirmation vote in the Verkhovna Rada ¹. Khmara is the acting head of the SBU, Ukraine's domestic security and intelligence service, and previously commanded its Alpha Special Operations Centre. Zelenskyy cited his record in long-range strike operations.

The succession went wrong in public before it landed there. Interior Minister Ihor Klymenko was floated for the post between 13 and 15 July, declined it, and took the National Security and Defence Council secretary role instead. Ukraine therefore spent a day with its defence portfolio openly unfilled, and now has an acting minister whose confirmation is a parliamentary question rather than a settled one.

What Khmara brings is a special-operations record, and what he inherits is an administrative machine. The ministry's hardest open file is mobilisation: recruitment shortfalls, brigade formation, and the churn of infantry that neither deep strikes nor intelligence work touches. Russian officials were themselves discussing a fresh mobilisation wave for October , which sets a rough deadline on how long Kyiv has to fix its own intake before the arithmetic on the other side changes. Alpha runs small teams under short chains of command, compartmented from one another by design. Conscription policy runs the opposite way, through recruitment centres, courts and local administrations, and it is exactly the part of the job Fedorov was dismissed for not solving.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Ukraine needed someone to run the Defence Ministry after Fedorov's abrupt exit, and the first choice turned it down. Interior Minister Ihor Klymenko was floated for the job but declined it, taking a different senior security post instead. Zelenskyy then assigned Yevhen Khmara, the acting head of Ukraine's domestic security service (the SBU) and a former commander of its Alpha special-operations unit, to run the ministry's day-to-day duties while parliament decides whether to confirm him properly. The choice is notable because Khmara is a security and special-operations officer, not a career politician or administrator. Zelenskyy cited his experience in long-range strike operations as the reason for picking him.

Deep Analysis

Root Causes

Khmara inherits a ministry whose unresolved file is mobilisation, the same file Russian planners were separately discussing when they weighed their own October mobilisation wave; the appointment does not resolve that file, it hands it to an officer whose background is special operations rather than personnel administration.

The Verkhovna Rada's confirmation requirement creates a structural gap Zelenskyy cannot bridge by decree alone: he can install Khmara in an acting capacity immediately, but cannot guarantee lawmakers will confirm a security-service pick who has no legislative track record and comes from Alpha's classified operational culture.

Source Landscape

This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Primary parallel: Zelenskyy's February 2024 replacement of Zaluzhny with Syrskyi ran on the same logic now repeated one level down: an officer with a concrete operational record chosen over an administrator to close a friction point with the front line.

Counter-parallel: Klymenko's own refusal of the post a day earlier is the closer cautionary case; Khmara still needs a Verkhovna Rada confirmation vote that no rushed nomination in this cycle has yet secured, unlike Syrskyi's clean 2024 handover.

Consensus view: Khmara takes over a ministry whose named unfixed problem is recruitment and brigade quality, and his deep-strike record suits a war being fought increasingly at range rather than through mass infantry manoeuvre; Zelenskyy's own stated rationale, technological and long-range strike experience, points the same way.

Counter-view: Alpha Special Operations Centre training builds long-range strike and hostage-rescue skills, not the recruitment-office and brigade-staffing work the ministry has been failing at; an officer credentialled in one does not thereby carry a demonstrated record in the other.

Key tension: The appointment is provisional, pending a Verkhovna Rada confirmation vote, so the choice may not survive contact with parliament regardless of which reading of Khmara's fit turns out to be correct.

Sources:Forbes Ukraine·Forbes Ukraine

Mentions:Volodymyr Zelenskyy →Verkhovna Rada →Kyiv →Ukraine →Yevhen Khmara →Ihor Klymenko →

First Reported In

Update #24 · Fedorov sacked as the front stands still

Forbes Ukraine· 19 Jul 2026

Read original →

Causes and effects

Caused by

Russia eyes a quiet October call-up

Khmara, a deep-strike officer, takes over a ministry whose unresolved file is mobilisation, the same file Russian planners were working against when they discussed their own October mobilisation wave.

Occurred 24 Jun 2026

Read story →

This Event

SBU officer Khmara takes defence duties

A long-range strike officer now runs a ministry whose unresolved file is mobilisation.

Led to

Legal fight over acting defence chief

Khmara's 16 July assignment as acting minister was formalised by cabinet order on 20 July.

Occurred 20 Jul 2026

Read story →

Different Perspectives

Belarus

Minsk announced completion of its own 37th Separate Airborne Assault Brigade near Gomel, under plans dating to August 2025 rather than a response to any single frontline event this window, keeping its hedge of hosting the war without formally joining Russia's mobilisation drive.

European Union / Operation IRINI states

Italy, Greece and Poland boarded the sanctioned tanker Toa Payoh off Pantelleria under a standing EU mandate rather than a national decision, extending enforcement from the Channel and Baltic and the Black Sea and Azov into the Mediterranean. Italian Defence Minister Guido Crosetto praised the crew; the captain's refusal to produce documentation left detention unconfirmed.

Poland and the NATO eastern flank

Warsaw's Coordination Team said explicitly its forces tracked the 30 July missile incursion and were ready to shoot it down, then flew air cover for an EU tanker interdiction three days later. Poland is simultaneously the war's nearest spillover victim and a contributor to enforcing sanctions against the state causing that spillover.

Ukraine (government, defence establishment and civilians)

Kyiv runs its manpower crisis through acting Defence Minister Yevhen Khmara, whose formal appointment waits for parliament's 18 August return, and a fortnight-old Commander-in-Chief, Mykhailo Drapatyi. Reported attacks on enlistment officers rose from 5 cases in 2022 to 341 in 2025, reaching Odesa's Territorial Recruitment Centre staff directly on 2 August.

Kremlin and Russian domestic economic voices

Moscow has not addressed July's advance-rate collapse or Sberbank's OFZ warning; Novak's diary ran to OPEC+ quota diplomacy with no diesel item logged since 15 July. Economist Nikolai Korzhenevsky calls the Central Bank's RUB 2.3tn in bank lending effectively deficit monetisation, a framing Sberbank's Skvortsov, with his own institutional interest, has not disputed.

IAEA (Rafael Grossi)

IAEA inspectors logged Zaporizhzhia's 22nd loss of off-site power, ten of them in the last three months, after a thunderstorm knocked out the plant's sole surviving backup line. Grossi reads the accelerating frequency, not any single outage, as the safety signal now that the plant's redundancy is exhausted.