Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Nomads & Communities
22OCT

Nusa Penida's new gate doubles takings

3 min read
16:46UTC

Klungkung Regency took 2.7bn rupiah on Nusa Penida in nine September days after moving to single-gate collection, while Bali's own foreign-visitor levy stayed at about 43% compliance.

SocietyDeveloping
Key takeaway

Bali's foreign-visitor levy still reaches only about 43% of arrivals while Nusa Penida's gate takings rise.

Klungkung Regency, the Balinese district that governs the Nusa islands, took 2.7bn rupiah in tourism charges on Nusa Penida from 1 to 9 September, against 1.1bn in the first ten days of August, after switching to single-gate collection⁠1. The regency's charge on foreign visitors began on 1 September. Its tourism office gave no visitor count, and the old per-site charge also fell on domestic visitors, so the figure shows revenue, not how many foreigners paid.

Bali's own levy reached about 43% of foreign visitors by 20 September, the same share as in August, after airlines were asked to announce it from late August. About 57% of foreign arrivals still do not pay it. Governor Wayan Koster said carriers need time to change their procedures⁠2.

The Ngurah Rai Immigration Office said on 29 September it had deported a foreign national who worked as a motorcycle instructor on a Remote Worker limited-stay permit (ITAS, Indonesia's temporary stay permit)⁠3. The remote-worker category is meant for people who work for employers abroad, and the case shows that local paid work on it can end in deportation.

On 30 September Indonesia's Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) passed the file in its alleged residence-permit extortion case to prosecutors, with eight suspects, including former deputy immigration minister Silmy Karim⁠4. A Jakarta court had rejected Karim's pre-trial challenge the day before. The KPK alleges 145.5bn rupiah was extracted from foreign applicants. Karim was dismissed in June and his detention was extended that month. No court has tried the allegations.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Bali charges foreign tourists a levy. A small island, Nusa Penida, now collects its own charge at one gate instead of several sites. In nine days it collected more than double what it collected in ten days of August. Separately, immigration officers deported a foreign national who held a remote-worker permit but worked as a motorcycle instructor. That permit is for people who work for employers abroad. Indonesia's anti-corruption commission also says officials took money from foreigners seeking residence permits. Prosecutors now have the case file.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Collection method explains the Nusa Penida result. Regional Regulation 4/2026 set 25,000 rupiah for foreign adults and 15,000 rupiah for foreign children from 1 September , and the regency moved to single-gate collection in place of site-by-site charges. Lowdown's reading is that fewer payments leak when a visitor pays once, at one point.

Bali's levy leaks because it depends on third parties. Governor Wayan Koster said airlines need time to change their procedures, and the levy was only announced by carriers from late August .

The extortion case has an institutional cause that the earlier record shows. The deputy minister post has been vacant since 4 June, the Acting Director General of Immigration is among the suspects, and the Directorate of Residence Permits has had two of three senior posts empty or under investigation .

What could happen next?
  • Consequence

    Foreigners who work locally on a remote-worker permit risk deportation and a place on the entry ban list.

    Immediate · Reported
  • Precedent

    Nusa Penida's gate model shows that collection at a physical chokepoint raises more than collection by third parties.

    Short term · Suggested
  • Risk

    A trial of senior former officials could expose how residence-permit decisions were priced for foreign applicants.

    Medium term · Suggested
First Reported In

Update #14 · Spain's Congress sinks its rental decrees

Bali Post· 3 Oct 2026
Read original →
Different Perspectives
KPK (Corruption Eradication Commission)
KPK (Corruption Eradication Commission)
KPK prosecutors filed Silmy Karim's case file with the Tipikor court on 19 October in the alleged residence-permit extortion case. Foreigners on a KITAS, remote workers included, apply and renew through the same immigration system; the charges have not been tested in court.
Consejo Hotelero del Caribe Mexicano
Consejo Hotelero del Caribe Mexicano
The Caribbean hotel council, backed by 44 business organisations, said on 15 October that cutting the entry-fee rise to 17.8% was not enough and asked the Senate to stop it. Yucatán's business council asked senators to reconsider two days later.
Shinjuku City
Shinjuku City
The ward opened comment on 15 October on rules barring new minpaku from its residential zones. It has 3,749 notified minpaku, which the ward says is the most of any Japanese municipality, and has issued 163 improvement orders, 67 suspension orders and 15 closure orders.
Peter Burke, Ireland's enterprise and tourism minister
Peter Burke, Ireland's enterprise and tourism minister
Burke presented the Short Term Letting and Tourism Bill on 6 October, making Fáilte Ireland the register authority and planning compliance a condition of registration. Hosts in places under 20,000 people get two years to regularise.
Izba Gospodarcza Hotelarstwa Polskiego (hotel industry chamber)
Izba Gospodarcza Hotelarstwa Polskiego (hotel industry chamber)
The IGHP warned that aparthotels could be caught by the municipal short-let zones in the act the Sejm passed on 8 October. Aparthotels sit between hotel and flat, and the act makes every stay under 30 days a regulated hotel service.
Apartur (Barcelona tourist-flat operators)
Apartur (Barcelona tourist-flat operators)
Apartur said it will sue Barcelona City Council if the December plenary confirms the IBI surcharge on tourist flats, which director general Marian Muro called disproportionate. The top band falls on owners of four or more, who hold about 6,000 of the city's roughly 10,600 tourist flats.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.