Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Data Centres: Boom and Backlash
15NOV

Brazil ties tax break to water cap

3 min read
23:07UTC

Brazil's Senate passed PL 278/2026 on 1 September, capping water use at 0.05 litres per kilowatt-hour. Miss the cap in any single year and the tax break goes.

IndustryDeveloping
Key takeaway

Brazil's tax break demands 0.05 litres per kWh, verified annually, which rules out evaporative cooling.

Brazil's Senado Federal, the country's upper house, approved PL 278/2026 on 1 September without changes of merit, sending it to President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva for signature rather than back to the Chamber of Deputies⁠1. The bill creates Redata, what Brazil's legislation calls a special taxation regime for data-centre services. It suspends Import Tax, PIS/Cofins and PIS/Cofins-Importation, the federal contributions charged on gross revenue and on imports, along with IPI, the federal tax on industrialised products.

Five conditions ride on the benefit. The one that bites is written as water use efficiency, or WUE, the litres a facility consumes for each kilowatt-hour of computing energy, capped at 0.05 litres per kWh and verified annually. An operator must also draw its power from renewable or low-emission sources, direct at least 10% of actual processing and storage supply to the domestic market, invest in Brazil the equivalent of 2% of the value of products bought under the benefit, and publish an annual sustainability report on the installations⁠2.

A ceiling that low rules out evaporative cooling, the method that sheds heat by letting water evaporate and which accounts for most data-centre water draw. What survives the test is closed-loop cooling, where the same coolant circulates and rejects its heat to air, or air cooling outright. Brasilia has written a design mandate and attached a tax break to it.

Two other jurisdictions attached conditions to data-centre support in the same month. Gujarat tied its subsidies to a green-power test, and Taiwan put a supply condition on its own large users. Redata goes further on one point: the test repeats every year and the benefit can be withdrawn, so a cooling design is not signed off once at approval but re-examined by the tax authority for the working life of the building. Government estimates and the Brazilian energy press give different totals for the tax forgone, on what appear to be different bases, so no headline value belongs in print. PL 278/2026 is passed, not law, and Lula has not yet signed it.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Cooling a data centre usually means evaporating water, like a swamp cooler, which costs less to build but uses far more water than a closed-loop system that reuses the same water repeatedly. Brazil's new bill sets the water limit so low that evaporative cooling essentially will not qualify for the tax break. That pushes operators toward pricier, more water-efficient equipment if they want the tax relief.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Redata's water clause exists because Brazil's federal government wants the concession to buy a specific outcome beyond investment volume alone. A capacity incentive with no efficiency condition, the model most jurisdictions used through the 2010s, let operators bank the subsidy while choosing whichever cooling method was cheapest to build, typically evaporative.

Tying the benefit to an annually verified number removes that choice: the operator either designs for the number from day one or forfeits the concession retroactively, which shifts the compliance cost onto the operator's balance sheet rather than the tax authority's enforcement budget.

What could happen next?
  • Precedent

    A large emerging-market economy has written a numeric, annually re-verified environmental condition directly into a tax bill rather than into planning guidance, which other Latin American and African regulators drafting data-centre incentives may copy.

First Reported In

Update #14 · Brazil bill ties tax break to a water cap

Senado Noticias· 8 Sept 2026
Read original →
Different Perspectives
Mooresville Board of Commissioners
Mooresville Board of Commissioners
The town board north of Charlotte voted unanimously on 2 November to stop taking data-centre applications for 12 months. Commissioners cited environmental and electrical impacts, joining other North Carolina towns that have paused new projects.
Naver
Naver
Naver signed a US$9bn contract under which a Brookfield vehicle owns the GPUs and buildings and sells computing to Naver Cloud. It guarantees the fees for up to eight years, which also unlocked Nvidia's US$1bn equity investment.
Saudi Aramco
Saudi Aramco
Aramco closed its purchase of 49% of HUMAIN on 1 November, paying about US$2.6bn in cash and adding its own AI, compute and digital assets. Chief executive Amin Nasser cast the deal as a gain in technology standing.
NEXTDC board
NEXTDC board
The board called the Goodman and Digital Realty stake opportunistic and said it had received no takeover proposal. It enters the 20 November meeting with a new chairman search, a 10% fee cut and a spill resolution on the agenda.
Brasscom
Brasscom
Sergio Sgobbi of Brazil's technology industry association says investors face uncertainty until the Redata rules are public. Members need rulings on gas and the CDE levy after Lula said data centres must build their own power.
Johari Abdul Ghani, Malaysia's investment, trade and industry minister
Johari Abdul Ghani, Malaysia's investment, trade and industry minister
He told the Dewan Rakyat in October that data centres pay for all the grid capacity they reserve and fund upgrades to TNB's network. Google's 4 November pledge repeats those terms as its own.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.