Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Data Centres: Boom and Backlash
4AUG

Tax fight kills Virginia projects early

3 min read
10:53UTC

Compass Datacenters walked away from two Greensville County and Emporia sites before filing a single planning application, with Finance Secretary Mark Sickles telling the Senate Finance Committee tax uncertainty alone drove the exit.

IndustryDeveloping
Key takeaway

State fiscal uncertainty is now cancelling data-centre projects upstream of the permitting process entirely.

Compass Datacenters halted its search for two sites in Greensville County and Emporia, Virginia, and Finance Secretary Mark Sickles told the Senate Finance Committee the projects were lost to tax uncertainty alone, before a single planning application was filed.⁠1 Virginia's state budget has been stalled since early March over whether to end the data-centre tax exemption eight years early. Senate Finance chair Louise Lucas wants it gone by 2026; the House wants it extended to 2035. For Southside counties that means jobs averaging $100,000 a year walked away from places where the median household earns $56,759.

The Virginia Court of Appeals voided Prince William's Digital Gateway rezoning earlier in the spring, and Compass withdrew there too; the county then dropped its appeal, extinguishing a 2,000-acre plan. Those fights bit at the planning stage. The Compass exit this time happened before any application existed, which shows the constraint moving upstream of permitting entirely.

Virginia built its cluster on a 2035 abatement commitment. Unwinding it retroactively makes the state legally unreliable for anything committed from 2026 on, and it puts the forward pipeline of the world's most concentrated data-centre market at risk through fiscal policy rather than zoning refusal.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Virginia has been offering data-centre companies a special tax break on the equipment they buy, exempting them from sales tax on servers and networking gear. This exemption runs until 2035 and was a major reason Virginia became home to the world's largest concentration of data centres, around Loudoun County near Washington DC. Senate Finance chair Louise Lucas wants to end the exemption in 2026, eight years early. The House wants to keep it to 2035. The two sides have been deadlocked since March, stalling the entire state budget. Compass Datacenters was quietly scouting two sites in Southside Virginia, a poorer rural area south of Richmond, for new campuses. Before filing any formal applications, it stopped looking. Finance Secretary Mark Sickles told a Senate committee those two opportunities were lost purely because of the tax uncertainty. At $100,000 average salary, those jobs matter enormously in counties where households earn a median of $56,759.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Virginia's 2035 abatement commitment was extended in 2018 as a competitive response to Amazon's HQ2 site search, making it part of the implicit contract that drew $100bn-plus of campus investment into Northern Virginia over seven years.

The fiscal-backlash pressure is directly proportional to the cluster's success: every new campus that opens increases the abatement's annual cost to the state's general fund, making it politically visible to constituents outside the data-centre corridor. Senator Lucas's district in Portsmouth is not a data-centre beneficiary, which structurally positions the Senate Finance chair as a voice for the abatement's cost rather than its benefits.

What could happen next?
  • Risk

    If the abatement is cut retroactively, projects already announced but not yet under construction could trigger force-majeure clauses in site agreements, unwinding investment that Virginia's economic development pipeline has already counted.

  • Consequence

    Southside Virginia counties, which have weaker alternative economic attractors than Northern Virginia, absorb the greatest employment loss from pipeline cancellations.

First Reported In

Update #4 · Grid wins power to switch off data centres

Cardinal News· 26 May 2026
Read original →
Causes and effects
This Event
Tax fight kills Virginia projects early
A retroactive tax change reaches projects that have not reached planning at all, threatening the pipeline of the world's most concentrated data-centre cluster through fiscal means rather than zoning.
Different Perspectives
Chilean data-centre developers
Chilean data-centre developers
Seven projects, one linked to Google, asked SEA this month for rulings that they fall outside full environmental review; four declared diesel-storage volumes just under the review-triggering tonnage, mirroring the mechanism Alto Jahuel used in July. The clustering suggests the threshold is being engineered, not sized to need.
An Coimisiun Pleanala
An Coimisiun Pleanala
Ireland's planning appeals body refused the €1.5bn Killala data centre on 17 September, overturning Mayo County Council's 2025 grant for lack of a fixed grid-connection agreement and no corporate renewable power-purchase agreement. The ruling makes matched-power evidence, not planning consent alone, the deciding factor.
Housing Assembly and Foxglove
Housing Assembly and Foxglove
The two groups' 6 August appeal, filed through the Legal Resources Centre, kept Cape Town's approval of Equinix's data centre suspended through this window over missing water, emissions, noise and diesel-generator data. Deputy Mayor Eddie Andrews confirmed on 20-21 September that the suspension holds.
Brazil (President Lula, signing Redata)
Brazil (President Lula, signing Redata)
Lula signed Lei 15.504 on 15 September, creating the Redata tax programme and keeping the Senate's water cap with no veto, while Aneel authorised Scala's AI City to join the national grid from January 2028. Brazil is recruiting capacity other markets are now turning away.
Aragon regional government (Eva Valle)
Aragon regional government (Eva Valle)
Aragon's economy chief Eva Valle said on 11 September that Spain's draft decree, requiring 80% hourly-matched renewables via a 10-year power-purchase agreement, is unmeetable by any project and threatens Blackstone, Azora and Microsoft builds already under way. Aragon holds 3,600 MW of granted grid access against 108 MW built.
Texas Governor Greg Abbott
Texas Governor Greg Abbott
Abbott ordered TCEQ on 21 September to halt every pending data-centre permit until projects pay their own way and complete ERCOT and Texas Water Development Board audits. Texas built the country's most permissive data-centre market; freezing it signals even that market has hit its grid limit.