Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Data Centres: Boom and Backlash
4AUG

Oregon PUC delays its data-centre tariff

3 min read
10:53UTC

The Oregon PUC delayed Portland General Electric's 29% large-load rate rise and the matching 1.3% household cut to 7 July, citing 200 pages of tariff updates staff had not yet reviewed.

IndustryDeveloping
Key takeaway

Oregon's data-centre tariff is filed but frozen until 7 July, so the cost shift onto operators exists only on paper.

Oregon's Public Utility Commission (PUC, the state regulator that sets electricity rates) delayed Portland General Electric's (PGE) proposed 29% large-load rate rise, and the matching 1.3% household bill cut, to a decision on 7 July⁠1. PUC chair Letha Tawney cited roughly 200 pages of tariff updates that staff needed time to review. PGE had filed the rise under the Oregon POWER Act, a state law that attributes grid-reinforcement costs to large loads such as data centres, and it filed as the first US utility to turn such a law into an actual tariff.

Neither side of the tariff has taken effect. The 29% increase and the residential reduction are both on hold, which means the precedent everyone cited, that operators rather than households absorb grid costs, exists on paper and nowhere else. A delay is not a defeat, but it is not the clean win the framing implied either. If the commission trims the 29% figure on 7 July or reopens the cost-attribution method, Oregon's claim to be first to implement the mechanism narrows to first to file it.

The stall mirrors the procedural friction holding up Virginia's capacity fee, where a cancelled session rather than a hostile vote is what blocks the charge. Both instruments now wait on a calendar rather than a count of yeses and noes, and both aim at the same large data-centre loads. The mechanism advances even where no decision has landed, which is a different kind of progress from a vote won.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Oregon has a law called the POWER Act (Prioritising Operational and Wholesale Energy Responsibility) that says electricity companies must charge big users, like data centres, the true cost of the extra grid upgrades needed to serve them, instead of spreading those costs across ordinary households. Portland General Electric (PGE), the main electricity company in the Portland area, filed a plan to raise rates for large data centres by 29% and cut household bills by 1.3%, putting the Oregon law into practice for the first time in the US. The state's Public Utility Commission (PUC), the regulator that must approve this kind of rate change, asked for more time to study the 200-page filing and set 7 July as its new decision date. No bills have changed yet. The delay means everyone is waiting to see whether Oregon's regulator actually approves the model, which would give 12 other US states that are considering similar laws a real-world example to point to.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Two structural gaps explain why Oregon needed the POWER Act at all. First, utility tariff law in the US defaults to average-cost pricing: all customers in a rate class pay the system-average cost of serving them, even when a single customer class drives the majority of new infrastructure investment.

Data centres above 20 MW drew enough load growth in PGE's service territory to require substation upgrades whose cost, under the pre-POWER Act default, would have been spread across PGE's 900,000 residential customers.

Second, FERC's jurisdiction over wholesale electricity transmission means that a state regulator can only set the retail rate; it cannot compel FERC to attribute transmission upgrade costs in a particular way. The POWER Act is a retail-side instrument operating within that boundary.

Its enforceability depends on the PUC approving the tariff filing and on no party successfully invoking FERC jurisdiction to preempt the state rate structure, a risk that becomes more concrete once FERC acts on RM26-4-000.

What could happen next?
  • Precedent

    A 7 July PUC approval of PGE's tariff would give 12 other states carrying active cost-attribution bills a filed, approved tariff with specific rate figures to cite in their own proceedings.

  • Risk

    If a PUC modification reduces the 29% figure materially, operators will use the revised number to argue that a properly calibrated cost-attribution tariff imposes less than half the headline rate, undercutting the deterrent effect in other states.

First Reported In

Update #7 · Virginia taxes the backup, not the draw

OPB· 17 Jun 2026
Read original →
Different Perspectives
Chilean data-centre developers
Chilean data-centre developers
Seven projects, one linked to Google, asked SEA this month for rulings that they fall outside full environmental review; four declared diesel-storage volumes just under the review-triggering tonnage, mirroring the mechanism Alto Jahuel used in July. The clustering suggests the threshold is being engineered, not sized to need.
An Coimisiun Pleanala
An Coimisiun Pleanala
Ireland's planning appeals body refused the €1.5bn Killala data centre on 17 September, overturning Mayo County Council's 2025 grant for lack of a fixed grid-connection agreement and no corporate renewable power-purchase agreement. The ruling makes matched-power evidence, not planning consent alone, the deciding factor.
Housing Assembly and Foxglove
Housing Assembly and Foxglove
The two groups' 6 August appeal, filed through the Legal Resources Centre, kept Cape Town's approval of Equinix's data centre suspended through this window over missing water, emissions, noise and diesel-generator data. Deputy Mayor Eddie Andrews confirmed on 20-21 September that the suspension holds.
Brazil (President Lula, signing Redata)
Brazil (President Lula, signing Redata)
Lula signed Lei 15.504 on 15 September, creating the Redata tax programme and keeping the Senate's water cap with no veto, while Aneel authorised Scala's AI City to join the national grid from January 2028. Brazil is recruiting capacity other markets are now turning away.
Aragon regional government (Eva Valle)
Aragon regional government (Eva Valle)
Aragon's economy chief Eva Valle said on 11 September that Spain's draft decree, requiring 80% hourly-matched renewables via a 10-year power-purchase agreement, is unmeetable by any project and threatens Blackstone, Azora and Microsoft builds already under way. Aragon holds 3,600 MW of granted grid access against 108 MW built.
Texas Governor Greg Abbott
Texas Governor Greg Abbott
Abbott ordered TCEQ on 21 September to halt every pending data-centre permit until projects pay their own way and complete ERCOT and Texas Water Development Board audits. Texas built the country's most permissive data-centre market; freezing it signals even that market has hit its grid limit.