5NOV

Two Dan Sullivans, one Alaska toss-up

1 min read

00:50UTC

Alaska's Supreme Court put a second Dan Sullivan back on the Senate primary ballot on 29 June, and Cook moved the race to Toss-up two days later.

← Back to Democrats take the Senate and the House Jump to analysis ↓

PoliticsDeveloping

Key takeaway

A second Dan Sullivan on the ballot turned a safe Republican seat into a toss-up.

The Alaska Supreme Court reinstated Dan J. Sullivan of Petersburg to the 18 August Senate primary ballot on 29 June, overturning the state Division of Elections' disqualification of him for a bad-faith filing. the Court found the good-faith test the elections director had applied appears nowhere in Alaska's constitution, statute or regulation. Dan J. Sullivan shares no family tie with Senator Dan S. Sullivan.

He now runs against Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan and Democratic recruit Mary Peltola under Alaska's top-four ranked-choice system, in which the four leading primary candidates advance and voters rank them in the general election. Two identically named Republicans on one ballot let a voter who means the senator rank the challenger first by mistake. Under ranked-choice counting, those stray first preferences can tip a close multi-round tally.

Cook Political Report moved Alaska Senate from Lean Republican to Toss-up on 1 July, citing that siphon risk directly. A seat the party had banked on holding now turns on ballot design rather than on any shift in what voters want. Alaska's Division of Elections has not said how it will distinguish the two names in August.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Alaska's Supreme Court put a second candidate named Dan Sullivan back on the primary ballot, running against the sitting Republican senator, who is also named Dan Sullivan. Election officials had tried to keep the newcomer off the ballot over fears voters would be confused about which one they were voting for. Alaska uses ranked-choice voting, where voters rank candidates in order of preference, but that system was not built to solve name confusion. Cook Political Report has already moved the race from favouring the incumbent to a genuine toss-up.

Deep Analysis

Root Causes

Alaska's top-four ranked-choice primary was designed to prevent vote-splitting between similar candidates by letting voters rank every option. That design assumes voters can tell the candidates apart in the first place.

When two candidates share an identical name and party label, ranking both does not resolve the underlying problem: a voter who cannot identify which Sullivan is the incumbent may rank them interchangeably, diluting the incumbent's first-choice advantage regardless of how the ballot is structured. The reinstatement exploits a gap in RCV's anti-spoiler design rather than a flaw the system was built to catch.

Sources:Anchorage Daily News

Mentions:Alaska Supreme Court →Mary Peltola →Cook Political Report →Alaska →Sabato's Crystal Ball →Scott Kendall →Dan S. Sullivan →Dan J. Sullivan →Kyle Kondik →

First Reported In

Update #12 · Voter-data drive stalls; jobs turn soft

Anchorage Daily News· 9 Jul 2026

Read original →

Causes and effects

Caused by

Alaska blocks the second Dan Sullivan

The Alaska Supreme Court's reinstatement reversed the Division of Elections' 15 June disqualification.

Occurred 12 Jun 2026

Read story →

This Event

Two Dan Sullivans, one Alaska toss-up

A name-duplicate quirk under ranked-choice voting can shave a decisive few points from an incumbent without a single voter changing their mind.

Led to

Peltola leads Sullivan by 0.3 points

Dan J. Sullivan, reinstated to the ballot in June, holds part of the first choices the ranked-choice count will redistribute.

Occurred 4 Nov 2026

Read story →

Different Perspectives

Missouri voters

Missouri voters rejected Proposition A by 61.83% to 38.17% at 95% reporting, repealing the 2025 map that split Kansas City. Trump carried the state, yet its 2022 lines now stay for future elections too.

Senate Leadership Fund (SLF)

SLF reported about $43.9m of independent expenditures from 27 October to 1 November, almost all against Democrats, including $12.37m against Sherrod Brown. Seven of its ten targets won; Dan Osborn lost in Nebraska and two are uncalled.

Richard Hudson, chair of the National Republican Congressional Committee

Hudson, who runs House Republicans' campaign arm, conceded North Carolina's 9th District to Richard Ojeda before any AP call. Democrats lead 10 of the state's 14 House districts on the unofficial feed.

Department of Justice (DOJ)

DOJ lost before Judge David O. Carter on 28 October and a 9th Circuit panel on 30 October on its demand to set aside 20,000 California ballots, and says it will appeal the Alaska dismissal. No court has set a ballot aside.

Senator Dan S. Sullivan

Sullivan, who trails Mary Peltola 48.2% to 47.9% on first choices, told CNN he would accept the result. DOJ's suit to stop Alaska certifying anyone but him was dismissed on 1 November.

Scott Colom's campaign

Colom's campaign estimates that about 15,000 affidavit ballots remain to be counted in a race he leads by roughly 65 to 100 votes. Those ballots count only if voters confirm their ID or eligibility by 5pm on 10 November.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.