Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Is Britain Actually Broke?
16NOV

We left the UK row of the table empty

3 min read
13:49UTC

The IMF's tables, statistical appendix and DataMapper interface returned access errors across five URLs on two attempts, so this briefing publishes a G7 debt comparison with no British figure in it.

EconomicDeveloping
Key takeaway

A blank cell with a stated reason beats a plausible figure measuring the wrong thing.

The International Monetary Fund April 2026 World Economic Outlook puts general government gross debt at 204.4% of GDP in Japan, 138.4% in Italy, 125.8% in the United States, 118.4% in France, 110.7% in Canada and 64.6% in Germany⁠1. Germany is the only G7 member below 100%. Those six figures reach us through a secondary compilation of the IMF database rather than the IMF's own tables, which is a weaker provenance than every other cell in this briefing.

We left the British row blank on purpose. The IMF's tables, statistical appendix and DataMapper interface returned access errors across five separate URLs on two independent attempts this run, so we do not hold a UK figure on that standardised basis. The temptation is to reach for the 94.9% net debt figure the Office for National Statistics publishes and drop it in. That would be wrong twice over: public sector net debt is a different measure on a different definition, and general government gross debt already puts the UK above 100% on the IMF's convention. Two numbers in the same column measuring different things is the exact error this register was built to avoid, and a blank cell with a stated reason is more useful to a reader than a plausible wrong one.

Two British positions do stand out against that peer group, pointing in opposite directions. The average maturity of the gilt stock was 13.9 years at the end of December 2025, longer than the G7 average⁠2. Long maturities mean only a fraction of the debt has to be refinanced in any one year, so a buyers' strike would hurt Britain slowly rather than overnight, which is a genuine and underrated buffer. Against that, the UK carries the highest share of index-linked debt in the G7, the feature that blocks the inflation route out.

This briefing attempts no per-ledger international comparison, and later runs will not either. Section 114 notices, Office for Students returns and Regulator of Social Housing gradings have no foreign equivalents to compare against. The next run will try the IMF statistical appendix again; until then the cell stays empty.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

When comparing how much different countries owe, economists use a standardised measure called general government gross debt, tracked by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) so that every country is measured the same way. This is different from the UK's own headline figure, public sector net debt, which uses a different definition and cannot simply be swapped in. This week, the IMF's own website blocked every attempt to retrieve the UK's specific figure on that standardised basis, so this briefing reports Japan, Italy, the United States, France, Canada and Germany's figures but leaves the UK's blank rather than guess or substitute a different measure that would compare apples to oranges.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

The IMF's World Economic Outlook database is the standardised source most cross-country debt comparisons rely on precisely because it applies one consistent methodology (general government gross debt) across member states, unlike each country's own domestic debt measure.

When that single source becomes technically unreachable, there is no equally authoritative substitute; a domestic figure like the UK's own PSND measure cannot simply be substituted, because it is not calculated on the same basis.

The access failure itself traces to standard web infrastructure (Akamai/edgesuite bot protection) applied to the IMF's domain, the kind of protection large institutional websites commonly deploy against automated scraping, which becomes a research obstacle specifically for anyone trying to fetch data programmatically rather than reading it manually in a browser.

What could happen next?
  • Risk

    Readers or other outlets substituting the ONS's 94.9% net-debt figure into an international gross-debt comparison table would be making a genuine category error, understating where the UK actually sits against G7 peers on the IMF's own convention.

First Reported In

Update #1 · The distress moved from banks to councils

Mappr· 27 Jul 2026
Read original →
Causes and effects
This Event
We left the UK row of the table empty
The obvious fix would be to drop Britain's 94.9% into the gap, and it would be a category error dressed up as completeness.
Different Perspectives
Institute of Economic Affairs
Institute of Economic Affairs
The Institute of Economic Affairs, a free-market think tank, proposed on 19 October, in a plan published before the Budget, suspending the state pension triple lock for three years and freezing welfare in cash terms. It looks to spending restraint where Tax Justice UK looks to tax; both plans are campaign positions, not findings.
Tax Justice UK
Tax Justice UK
Tax Justice UK, a left-leaning campaign group, called the Budget "another round of aimless tinkering" on 30 October and, on 4 November, said its new 10% capital gains rate for founders and investors was "difficult to justify". It argues ten tax reforms would raise over £60bn a year: a campaign position, not a finding.
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
The National Institute of Economic and Social Research, an independent forecaster, expects growth of 1.6% in 2026, against the Office for Budget Responsibility's 1.2%. It puts headroom at £14.5bn, down from £23.6bn in March, measured from a different starting point, so its figure does not confirm the official £15bn.
Institute for Government
Institute for Government
The Institute for Government, a non-partisan think tank, judged on 30 October that the Budget delayed the hard choices rather than making them. In its words, "most of the difficult decisions have been punted forward into 2027".
Resolution Foundation
Resolution Foundation
The Resolution Foundation, a centre-left think tank, said on 29 October that higher taxes do all the work in the Budget's numbers. The £76bn improvement in the primary balance from 2023-24 to 2028-29 "is more than fully accounted for by £107 billion of higher tax revenues", it wrote.
Bank of England
Bank of England
The Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee raised Bank Rate to 4% on 5 November, with all nine members backing a rise and one wanting 4.25%. The Bank projects inflation, 3.5% in September, at about 5% by the middle of 2027, so it is tightening while the government borrows more.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.