Sir John Major delivered the Attlee Foundation Lecture at King's College London on 18 March 2026, stating that recent general elections had "thrown into doubt the continuing validity of the First past the post system" and that it was "acting more erratically" as votes spread across more parties. He stopped short of endorsing proportional representation. The choice of venue is pointed: Clement Attlee's foundation, a Labour platform, chosen by a Conservative former Prime Minister to make the case that the English voting system is broken.
The venue choice is not incidental. The last senior Conservative to publicly question FPTP was Douglas Hurd in 1998. Since then the argument has belonged almost exclusively to the Liberal Democrats and the Electoral Reform Society, which has allowed defenders of FPTP to dismiss it as the self-interest of parties that do badly under the current system. Major's intervention removes that dismissal. He has no incentive: the Conservatives benefited from FPTP for most of his career.
On 7 May, England votes under FPTP, Scotland under the Additional Member System, and Wales under closed-list proportional representation for the first time . The contrast will be visible in the same night's results. If FPTP produces a significant gap between national vote share and seat share in England while the Welsh and Scottish systems track closer to proportionality, the Major speech becomes a reference point that is difficult to ignore in any post-election debate about Reform.
The Wales Governance Centre's consolidation thesis makes the comparison starker still: both Welsh blocs are hardening simultaneously. Under PR, each point of vote share converts to seats more faithfully. Under FPTP, concentrated vote produces wasted votes. On the same night, the same underlying polarisation will be expressed differently in each nation's results, and the difference will be on television simultaneously.
