Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here

The Record

Is Britain Actually Broke?

What we told you to watch, what each side claimed, and what we got wrong. Every verdict shows its evidence.

Open 23 · Corrections 25

What we told you to watch

Still open · 23

Show the 10 most recent
  • Whether the OBR cuts its 1.4% long-run productivity assumption by 0.1 to 0.2 percentage points at the next fiscal event, which would shrink fiscal headroom without any policy changing.

    From the 27 Jul briefing

  • Whether Ofwat accepts the London & Valley Water proposal for Thames Water, or the company enters the Special Administration Regime.

    From the 27 Jul briefing

  • Whether the £4.7bn deferred to Budget 2026 arrives as new money or as a further round of departmental reprioritisation.

    From the 27 Jul briefing

What each side claimed

Claims are what a named side said at the time. We record them as said and judge them only against later evidence.

No claims recorded yet.

What we got wrong

Show the 10 most recent
  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    The 28 October EFO would test whether the OBR's 1.4% productivity assumption survives.

    What was true

    The 1.4% figure is the average productivity growth assumed over the next 50 years in the OBR's July 2026 Fiscal risks and sustainability report. The 28 October Economic and fiscal outlook tests the medium-term path; the March 2026 EFO had underlying productivity growth reaching 1.0% a year by the end of its forecast. A medium-term downgrade could feed into the next long-term projection, but the October EFO does not directly retest the 1.4% fifty-year average.

  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    The 28 October EFO would test whether the OBR keeps its 1.4% long-run productivity assumption.

    What was true

    The 1.4% figure is the average productivity growth assumed over the next 50 years in the OBR's July 2026 Fiscal risks and sustainability report. The 28 October Economic and fiscal outlook tests the medium-term path; the March 2026 EFO had underlying productivity growth reaching 1.0% a year by the end of its forecast. A medium-term downgrade could feed into the next long-term projection, but the October EFO does not directly retest the 1.4% fifty-year average.

  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    The 28 October EFO would test whether the OBR cuts its 1.4% long-run productivity assumption.

    What was true

    The 1.4% figure is the average productivity growth assumed over the next 50 years in the OBR's July 2026 Fiscal risks and sustainability report. The 28 October Economic and fiscal outlook tests the medium-term path; the March 2026 EFO had underlying productivity growth reaching 1.0% a year by the end of its forecast. A medium-term downgrade could feed into the next long-term projection, but the October EFO does not directly retest the 1.4% fifty-year average.

  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    The next fiscal event would test whether the OBR cuts its 1.4% long-run productivity assumption.

    What was true

    The 1.4% figure is the average productivity growth assumed over the next 50 years in the OBR's July 2026 Fiscal risks and sustainability report. The 28 October Economic and fiscal outlook tests the medium-term path; the March 2026 EFO had underlying productivity growth reaching 1.0% a year by the end of its forecast. A medium-term downgrade could feed into the next long-term projection, but the October EFO does not directly retest the 1.4% fifty-year average.

  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    The £10.3bn Defence Investment Plan.

    What was true

    The plan adds £15bn; £10.3bn of its funding was identified on 30 June 2026.

  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    A £10.3bn Defence Investment Plan funding breakdown; a 1p capital budget cut.

    What was true

    A breakdown of the £15bn plan identifying £10.3bn; a 1% cut to departmental capital budgets.

    In £4bn of £10.3bn defence funding is a budget cut

  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    The defence plan is worth £10.3bn.

    What was true

    The plan adds £15bn over 2026-27 to 2029-30; £10.3bn is the funding identified on 30 June 2026, with £4.7bn left to Budget 2026.

    In £4bn of £10.3bn defence funding is a budget cut

  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    Assets of £1,112.6bn in July 2026.

    What was true

    The figures are as at 30 June 2026 (July update).

    In Pension schemes sit £264bn in surplus

  • MinorCorrected 22 Oct 2026
    We said

    The PPF 7800 showed 131.1% and £264.0bn in July 2026.

    What was true

    131.1% and £264.0bn are as at 30 June 2026, published in the July 2026 update; at 31 July the index was 133.0%.

    In Pension schemes sit £264bn in surplus

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    The Telegraph, relaying Newsquawk, reports that the Bank of England will stop active sales of 20- and 30-year gilts.

    What was true

    The Telegraph made the report and Newsquawk relayed it, as event 6213 and the update body already say.

    In 30-year gilt passes 6%, last seen 1998

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In Ofgem puts energy debt at £5.02bn

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In Bankruptcies up 14% in England and Wales

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In Sefton holds £3.2m against £104m deficit

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In Sefton holds £3.2m against £104m deficit

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In Sefton holds £3.2m against £104m deficit

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In Sefton holds £3.2m against £104m deficit

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In Bankruptcies up 14% in England and Wales

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In ONS puts borrowing £8.1bn over OBR path

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form

    In ONS puts borrowing £8.1bn over OBR path

  • MinorCorrected 7 Oct 2026
    We said

    Raw back-reference token left in reader prose

    What was true

    Token converted to the EVREF form