Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Is Britain Actually Broke?
16NOV

Adam Smith Institute puts top tax rate at 54%

2 min read
13:49UTC

The Adam Smith Institute put the revenue-maximising top income tax rate at 54% on 7 August; the IPPR argued a day earlier that shared procurement could free £3.4bn of borrowing headroom.

EconomicAssessed
Key takeaway

Two institutes published rival positions on financing defence, neither costed by the OBR.

The Adam Smith Institute published an argument on 7 August 2026 that raising income tax rates would reduce the revenue collected, putting the revenue-maximising top rate at 54%⁠1. A day earlier the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) argued that joint procurement and shared stockpiling with allies could create £3.4bn of borrowing headroom, set against a path to spending 3% of gross domestic product on defence by 2030 that it costs at about £13bn a year of extra spending in today's prices⁠2. The IPPR accepts in the same paper that a permanent commitment at that level still requires higher revenue or lower spending elsewhere.

Neither number is an outturn. The 54% comes from a campaigning free-market institute's modelling of taxpayer behaviour, the £3.4bn from a campaigning centre-left institute's modelling of procurement savings, and neither has been costed by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), the government's independent forecaster. This desk prints the pair without adjudicating between them, because adjudicating would mean adopting one side's model.

They belong in the same panel because they answer the same question from opposite ends. The defence path is a claim on the sovereign balance sheet with roughly £25bn a year of it unfunded on the OBR and Institute for Fiscal Studies assessments, and £3.5bn of the funding package published in June was one-off money that cannot repeat next year. One institute proposes to close that gap by spending less on the same capability, the other warns against closing it through the top rate of income tax. Neither institute has published a costing that the OBR or any comparable independent body has checked.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Two policy research organisations, called think tanks, published different proposals for the same underlying problem: how the government pays for rising costs such as defence spending, without borrowing more than markets are comfortable lending. The Adam Smith Institute, which generally favours lower taxes, argued that raising income tax further would raise less money than expected. The Institute for Public Policy Research, which generally favours a larger state role, argued that buying defence equipment jointly with allies could free up some borrowing room without a tax rise, though not enough to cover the whole bill on its own numbers.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

The Adam Smith Institute's 54% figure is a theoretical revenue-maximising rate, the estimated point on a Laffer-curve style calculation past which further rate rises are argued to lose more revenue through reduced work and avoidance than they gain from the higher rate.

It is the Institute's own modelled estimate, not an HMRC-observed effective rate.

What could happen next?
  • Meaning

    Both proposals are positions from bodies with declared policy leanings, not independent forecasts, and neither claims to fully resolve the underlying funding gap on its own.

First Reported In

Update #2 · Three household registers, three answers

Adam Smith Institute· 20 Aug 2026
Read original →
Causes and effects
This Event
Adam Smith Institute puts top tax rate at 54%
Both organisations published positions rather than findings, and both are arguing about how to pay for the same defence commitment.
Different Perspectives
Institute of Economic Affairs
Institute of Economic Affairs
The Institute of Economic Affairs, a free-market think tank, proposed on 19 October, in a plan published before the Budget, suspending the state pension triple lock for three years and freezing welfare in cash terms. It looks to spending restraint where Tax Justice UK looks to tax; both plans are campaign positions, not findings.
Tax Justice UK
Tax Justice UK
Tax Justice UK, a left-leaning campaign group, called the Budget "another round of aimless tinkering" on 30 October and, on 4 November, said its new 10% capital gains rate for founders and investors was "difficult to justify". It argues ten tax reforms would raise over £60bn a year: a campaign position, not a finding.
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
The National Institute of Economic and Social Research, an independent forecaster, expects growth of 1.6% in 2026, against the Office for Budget Responsibility's 1.2%. It puts headroom at £14.5bn, down from £23.6bn in March, measured from a different starting point, so its figure does not confirm the official £15bn.
Institute for Government
Institute for Government
The Institute for Government, a non-partisan think tank, judged on 30 October that the Budget delayed the hard choices rather than making them. In its words, "most of the difficult decisions have been punted forward into 2027".
Resolution Foundation
Resolution Foundation
The Resolution Foundation, a centre-left think tank, said on 29 October that higher taxes do all the work in the Budget's numbers. The £76bn improvement in the primary balance from 2023-24 to 2028-29 "is more than fully accounted for by £107 billion of higher tax revenues", it wrote.
Bank of England
Bank of England
The Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee raised Bank Rate to 4% on 5 November, with all nine members backing a rise and one wanting 4.25%. The Bank projects inflation, 3.5% in September, at about 5% by the middle of 2027, so it is tightening while the government borrows more.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.