Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Is Britain Actually Broke?
16NOV

Hillier's MPs seek 10-year OBR forecast

2 min read
13:49UTC

The Treasury Committee said on 23 September that the OBR's critics were shooting the messenger, and asked ministers to consider a ten-year forecast.

EconomicDeveloping
Key takeaway

MPs backed the OBR and want ministers to consider a ten-year forecast.

The Commons Treasury Committee rejected calls to overhaul the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) in a report published on 23 September, describing the forecaster's critics as "shooting the messenger"⁠1. It recommends that ministers consider asking the OBR for a ten-year forecast alongside its five-year one. It also wants Parliament to set aside time to debate the OBR's annual fiscal risks report.

Committee chair Meg Hillier said the rules and the forecasts matter more "when government spending operates on razor-thin margins". OBR chair Jonathan Haskel welcomed the report⁠2. The OBR's next forecast is due with the Budget, on the date it confirmed in July⁠3.

A ten-year horizon would show how pension and interest costs build beyond the five years on which each Budget is judged. The OBR already costs the State pension triple lock at £15.5bn a year by 2029-30, close to the far edge of the current window.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) is an independent body that predicts what the government will earn and spend. The Chancellor uses its forecast to check whether the Budget obeys the government's own borrowing rules. Some people have attacked the OBR when its forecasts turn out bad. A group of MPs, the Treasury Committee, says that is wrong: critics are blaming the person who brings bad news. The MPs also suggest a forecast that looks ten years ahead as well as five. They want Parliament to debate the OBR's yearly risks report too.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

The dispute exists because fiscal rules turn a forecast into a constraint. When headroom is thin, a revision of a few billion pounds decides whether a Chancellor needs to raise taxes, so attention shifts from the policy to the number.

The five-year horizon adds a second cause. Pension, health and interest costs build beyond five years, so a rule judged inside that window cannot show costs that arrive after it. The Committee's ten-year suggestion addresses that gap directly.

The OBR's remit sets a third constraint: it produces forecasts on current policy and cannot advise on what policy should be, so critics direct their anger at the forecast and not at the choices that produce it.

What could happen next?
  • Precedent

    A committee recommendation to ask for a ten-year forecast gives ministers a documented reason to commission one, with the first chance at the 28 October Budget.

  • Meaning

    Political backing for the OBR from the Commons committee raises the cost for any Chancellor of discounting its numbers.

First Reported In

Update #4 · £8.1bn over forecast, and the 30-year at 6%

Office for Budget Responsibility· 7 Oct 2026
Read original →
Different Perspectives
Institute of Economic Affairs
Institute of Economic Affairs
The Institute of Economic Affairs, a free-market think tank, proposed on 19 October, in a plan published before the Budget, suspending the state pension triple lock for three years and freezing welfare in cash terms. It looks to spending restraint where Tax Justice UK looks to tax; both plans are campaign positions, not findings.
Tax Justice UK
Tax Justice UK
Tax Justice UK, a left-leaning campaign group, called the Budget "another round of aimless tinkering" on 30 October and, on 4 November, said its new 10% capital gains rate for founders and investors was "difficult to justify". It argues ten tax reforms would raise over £60bn a year: a campaign position, not a finding.
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
The National Institute of Economic and Social Research, an independent forecaster, expects growth of 1.6% in 2026, against the Office for Budget Responsibility's 1.2%. It puts headroom at £14.5bn, down from £23.6bn in March, measured from a different starting point, so its figure does not confirm the official £15bn.
Institute for Government
Institute for Government
The Institute for Government, a non-partisan think tank, judged on 30 October that the Budget delayed the hard choices rather than making them. In its words, "most of the difficult decisions have been punted forward into 2027".
Resolution Foundation
Resolution Foundation
The Resolution Foundation, a centre-left think tank, said on 29 October that higher taxes do all the work in the Budget's numbers. The £76bn improvement in the primary balance from 2023-24 to 2028-29 "is more than fully accounted for by £107 billion of higher tax revenues", it wrote.
Bank of England
Bank of England
The Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee raised Bank Rate to 4% on 5 November, with all nine members backing a rise and one wanting 4.25%. The Bank projects inflation, 3.5% in September, at about 5% by the middle of 2027, so it is tightening while the government borrows more.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.