Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Is Britain Actually Broke?
16NOV

Borrowing over OBR plan for three months

3 min read
13:49UTC

Government borrowing ran over the OBR's March plan in July, August and September, the first of this desk's nine warning lines to be crossed.

EconomicAssessed
Key takeaway

Borrowing has run over the March plan for three straight months, but July holds the run by £0.9bn.

The Office for National Statistics (ONS) published figures on 21 October that put government borrowing above its March plan in July, August and September⁠1. Three months running over that plan is the line this desk declared on 27 July for its sovereign ledger, one of nine warning lines it tracks across Britain's finances. No other line has been crossed. Every pound borrowed over plan adds to an interest bill that taxes pay.

The plan is the monthly borrowing path drawn in March by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), the official forecaster⁠2. Borrowing beat it by £0.9bn in July, £2.5bn in August and £1.9bn in September. From April to September the government borrowed £97.841bn against a plan of £91.803bn, an overshoot of £6.0bn (£97.841bn - £91.803bn = £6.038bn). Shared across the UK's 29.0 million households, that is about £207 each (£6.0bn ÷ 29.0m = £207, our sum on the ONS household count for 2025): a measure of scale, not a bill any household receives.

The month-by-month count is ours; the ONS bulletin prints only the September gap and the six-month total⁠3. This desk should have counted the run on 22 October. Update #5 went out the day after these figures and reported the September gap and the half-year overshoot, but did not test them against the trigger. It printed nothing false. August had first been reported in September at £3.5bn over the path, before later revisions brought it down.

July holds the run by a thin margin. On its first print July was about £2.3bn over the plan, before the ONS cut April to August borrowing by £4.0bn. The ONS revises every month again in figures due on 20 November, and a cut of £0.87bn or more to July would break the run. The trigger stays tied to the March plan even though the OBR replaced it on 28 October, because a line that moved with each new forecast could never fire. Its second test, a gilt auction (a sale of the government's bonds) drawing less than £2 of bids for every £1 on offer, has not fired.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Each month the government spends more than it collects in tax, and borrows the difference. The Office for National Statistics (ONS), the official statistics body, counts that borrowing. In March the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), which forecasts the public finances, drew a month-by-month plan for the year. This desk set a warning line in July: three months running over that plan. July, August and September all came in over it, so the line has been crossed. The ONS revises old months each time it publishes, so the run could still be undone.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

Index-linked gilts feed inflation into monthly borrowing within weeks. In September, £4.0bn of the £10.9bn of central government debt interest was the inflation uplift on these bonds, which the ONS traced largely to a 0.6% rise in the Retail Prices Index between June and July.

The public payroll grows faster than the private one. Public sector regular pay rose 6.3% in cash terms in June to August against 3.0% in the private sector. The first is a cost the Treasury pays; the second drives the income tax it collects.

The March plan was fixed before the Autumn Budget's decisions. It could not include anything the government chose to spend or tax after March.

Escalation

Rising on one limb, flat on the other. The borrowing limb of the sovereign trigger has fired; the lender limb has not, with every gilt auction since 23 September well covered. The 20 November revisions decide whether the borrowing limb stays fired.

What could happen next?
  • Risk

    A downward revision to July on 20 November would end the three-month run on the latest vintage.

    Immediate · Assessed
  • Meaning

    September's accrued borrowing ran over plan while its cash need ran under, so gilt supply and the headline borrowing figure can move apart.

    Short term · Assessed
  • Precedent

    A trigger tied to a fixed March path can fire on data the forecaster has already replaced, which is why the desk keeps the original path.

    Medium term · Assessed
First Reported In

Update #6 · Britain is over its borrowing plan, not out of credit

Office for National Statistics· 16 Nov 2026
Read original →
Different Perspectives
Institute of Economic Affairs
Institute of Economic Affairs
The Institute of Economic Affairs, a free-market think tank, proposed on 19 October, in a plan published before the Budget, suspending the state pension triple lock for three years and freezing welfare in cash terms. It looks to spending restraint where Tax Justice UK looks to tax; both plans are campaign positions, not findings.
Tax Justice UK
Tax Justice UK
Tax Justice UK, a left-leaning campaign group, called the Budget "another round of aimless tinkering" on 30 October and, on 4 November, said its new 10% capital gains rate for founders and investors was "difficult to justify". It argues ten tax reforms would raise over £60bn a year: a campaign position, not a finding.
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
The National Institute of Economic and Social Research, an independent forecaster, expects growth of 1.6% in 2026, against the Office for Budget Responsibility's 1.2%. It puts headroom at £14.5bn, down from £23.6bn in March, measured from a different starting point, so its figure does not confirm the official £15bn.
Institute for Government
Institute for Government
The Institute for Government, a non-partisan think tank, judged on 30 October that the Budget delayed the hard choices rather than making them. In its words, "most of the difficult decisions have been punted forward into 2027".
Resolution Foundation
Resolution Foundation
The Resolution Foundation, a centre-left think tank, said on 29 October that higher taxes do all the work in the Budget's numbers. The £76bn improvement in the primary balance from 2023-24 to 2028-29 "is more than fully accounted for by £107 billion of higher tax revenues", it wrote.
Bank of England
Bank of England
The Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee raised Bank Rate to 4% on 5 November, with all nine members backing a rise and one wanting 4.25%. The Bank projects inflation, 3.5% in September, at about 5% by the middle of 2027, so it is tightening while the government borrows more.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.