Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Russia-Ukraine War 2026
1APR

Carbon sits still as gas and power dive

2 min read
16:30UTC

EUA December-2026 allowances closed at €83.51/tonne on 27 July against €83.40 on the 24th, a move of 0.01 per cent, through the sharpest four sessions of the cycle.

ConflictDeveloping
Key takeaway

Carbon moved a hundredth of a per cent while gas and power collapsed around it.

EUA December-2026 carbon allowances closed at €83.51/tonne on Monday 27 July against €83.40 on Friday the 24th, a change of 0.01 per cent.⁠1⁠2 Both prints are aggregator quotes on the EEX December-2026 contract rather than exchange settlement prints, and the aggregators disagree with each other: one secondary report gave €83.88 for the 24 July session, another a €80.01 to €81.07 range for the same day.⁠3 The two dedicated data services agree; the rest do not. Carbon has been range-bound for a fortnight, having drifted back under €81 in mid-July before recovering.

Hold that still print against what the other two spark inputs did across the identical four sessions. Gas handed back the war premium it had built on Gulf risk. German power lost more than two fifths of its value on a wind surge. Carbon moved by a hundredth of a per cent. This desk asked last week whether the carbon leg might ease the pressure on the spark. It did not, and it did not add to it either.

That flatness is doing analytical work. A single de-escalation trade would have pulled carbon with it, because a cheaper-gas world implies more coal-to-gas switching and firmer allowance demand at the margin. Carbon not moving says the market did not process the week as one story. It processed a geopolitical unwind in the fuel leg and a weather event in the revenue leg, and it correctly declined to price either as a change in Europe's emissions trajectory. For anyone modelling the spark, carbon is the input that has held still through every shock this cycle, which makes it the one whose eventual move will not be priced in advance.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Companies that burn fossil fuels in Europe have to buy a permit for every tonne of carbon dioxide they release. The price of that permit, called EUA carbon, barely moved this week even though the price of gas and the price of electricity both swung hard. That is because the carbon permit market runs on its own separate calendar, tied to European Union rules about how many permits exist each year, not to the day-to-day news that moves gas and power prices.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

EUA's own supply schedule, auction calendars and free-allocation cuts, is fixed months in advance, so the price only moves on new regulatory news rather than on daily gas or power prints; that is a structurally different price-formation process from TTF, which reacts to real-time flow data and geopolitical risk.

With no cap revision, auction change or CBAM announcement landing in this four-session window, carbon had no input to react to, which is why it held flat while two inputs that do react to daily news, gas and power, moved 8 and 41 per cent respectively.

What could happen next?
  • Meaning

    Carbon's inertia through both directions of this week's gas and power swing shows the ETS cap, not fuel news, is currently the dominant input on the allowance price.

First Reported In

Update #30 · Wind, not peace, sank the German spark

TradingEconomics· 27 Jul 2026
Read original →
Causes and effects
This Event
Carbon sits still as gas and power dive
Carbon holding flat while both other spark inputs collapsed is the cleanest evidence that two separate shocks hit, not one de-escalation trade.
Different Perspectives
Bulgarian government
Bulgarian government
Bulgaria's Prime Minister, Rumen Radev, said the sinking of HS Dignity "benefits the Russian Federation" while saying Bulgaria lacked solid evidence to accuse anyone, and Defence Minister Dimitar Stoyanov asked NATO for air defence on 16 October. The request comes from a government that stopped state military aid to Ukraine in June.
Radoslaw Sikorski
Radoslaw Sikorski
Poland's foreign minister challenged Elon Musk on X after SpaceX capped Ukraine's Starshield terminals on 14 October. Poland pays about $50m a year for Ukraine's Starlink subscriptions, so Warsaw speaks as the paying customer as well as the ally.
Andy Burnham
Andy Burnham
Burnham fast-tracked £10m of a £45m air-defence missile delivery when Zelenskyy visited London on 14 October, and his ministers are lobbying allies to ban maritime services for Russian liquefied natural gas. The measure targets insurers and shipowners, many of them in London, rather than the gas itself.
Ministry of External Affairs (India)
Ministry of External Affairs (India)
India's foreign ministry said after the 16 September House vote that New Delhi would take all necessary measures to protect its trade.
European Council
European Council
EU leaders on 15-16 October rejected a US idea to hand Washington the roughly €200bn of frozen Russian assets held in Europe, and Kaja Kallas said the decision belongs to Europeans. The same summit put off a decision on financing Ukraine, saying leaders "will revert to the issue in a timely manner".
Donald Trump
Donald Trump
Trump signed the 16 October order that sets the Graham Act's duties and waives them under section 115(a), with a certification sent to Congress. He says the United States has not stopped sharing intelligence with Ukraine, and on 11 October he said both sides had agreed to halt attacks on energy infrastructure.

Written with AI from Lowdown's published reporting. Not individually reviewed by an editor. Editorial standards.