12AUG

Labour crumbles in two more wards

1 min read

14:07UTC

On the same night Reform lost Old Catton, the Conservatives gained Dereham Toftwood and the Greens gained Fletton and Woodston, both from Labour, with Reform holding second in each.

← Back to Reform bleeds councillors, wins by-elections Jump to analysis ↓

PoliticsDeveloping

Key takeaway

Conservatives and Greens took two more seats from Labour, which lost ground in all three 16 July by-elections.

The Conservatives gained Dereham Toftwood on Breckland council from Labour on 16 July 2026, with Reform UK a strong new second on 36.9% and Labour's share down more than 35 points ¹. On the same night the Green Party gained Fletton and Woodston on Peterborough City Council, also from Labour, with Reform again holding second on 29.7% ².

The Fletton and Woodston seat fell vacant after a Labour councillor quit alleging "sustained bullying" over her push for closed-circuit television (CCTV) in taxis ³. Neither result unseated Reform; both unseated Labour, the same pattern visible in Reform's own loss at Old Catton the same evening.

Read across the three contests, Reform lost only where it was defending its own seat and grew where it attacked a Labour incumbent. Labour lost in all three. Burnham's party changed leaders this month to relieve exactly this pressure , and the first by-elections of his premiership deepened it instead.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

Two more council by-elections on 16 July went badly for Labour. The Conservatives took Dereham Toftwood from Labour in Norfolk, and the Green Party took Fletton and Woodston from Labour in Peterborough. Reform UK came second in both. A council by-election fills one vacant seat; it does not change who governs nationally. But a run of losses like this in a single day suggests Labour's support has weakened at the local level too, beyond what the national opinion polls show.

Deep Analysis

Root Causes

An unnamed Labour councillor's complaint of 'sustained bullying' in Peterborough points to local party organisation problems compounding the national polling slide, a structural weakness in activist bases Labour has not defended seriously since boundary changes, rather than a single cause.

Reform UK holding second place in both contests despite Labour's collapse shows the party's roughly 40 cumulative councillor losses nationally by early July have not yet cost it its position as the default opposition-to-Labour vote in these wards.

Source Landscape

This story draws on neutral-leaning sources

Consensus view: Professor Rob Ford of the University of Manchester has argued that repeated fourth and fifth-place finishes for Labour in wards it held only a few years ago reflect a genuine erosion of its core vote, because the same pattern is now visible across dozens of separate contests rather than one outlier result.

Counter-view: The Institute for Government has cautioned against reading too much into by-election vote shares on the low turnouts typical of these contests, arguing single-ward results reflect motivated opposition voters turning out rather than any broad shift in Labour's underlying support.

Key tension: Whether Labour's repeated low finishes signal a genuine collapse in its core vote, or the low-turnout dynamics that always favour whichever party is angriest at the government of the day.

Sources:Bin The Labour Party

Mentions:Green Party →Reform UK →Old Catton →Norfolk →Institute for Government →Labour Party →

First Reported In

Update #13 · England's council map redrawn as five sue

Bin The Labour Party· 24 Jul 2026

Read original →

Causes and effects

This Event

Labour crumbles in two more wards

Labour, not Reform, was the consistent loser across all three of the 16 July by-elections.

Led to

Clacton's ballot paper splits the right four ways

The two wards where the anti-Reform vote stayed split show Reform holding second place, contrasting with Old Catton.

Occurred 17 Jul 2026

Read story →

Greens take a seat Reform came second in

Continues the mid-July pattern of opposition parties consolidating against Reform and Labour incumbents in council by-elections.

Occurred 6 Aug 2026

Read story →

Different Perspectives

Sinn Féin

Sinn Féin's John O'Dowd ruled out a Stormont walkout on 11 August despite calling the DUP increasingly difficult to work with, closing a question Conor Murphy had left open a fortnight earlier. Only Sinn Féin or the DUP can collapse the joint First Minister office, so the denial gives up the party's own leverage in budget talks.

Scottish Labour

Michael Marra, Joe Fagan and Monica Lennon declared for the Scottish Labour leadership, but each needs nine endorsements from MSPs, MPs and unions before members vote, with nominations closing 17 August. Lennon, the only woman standing, says the threshold favours a male-run process and could produce an all-male ballot.

Plaid Cymru

Plaid Cymru held both Welsh wards Reform challenged in the same set of by-elections, Bro'r Llynnoedd on Anglesey by 48.5% to 39.3% and Hengoed on Caerphilly by 49.9% to 36.4%. The party that leads the Welsh government kept Reform in second in both.

Conservative Party

The Conservatives lost three of ten council by-elections fought on 30 July and 6 August, two wards to Reform in Norfolk and one to the Greens in Surrey, continuing a run of losses since the May sweep. Every seat gone had been Conservative-held going into the contest.

Reform UK

Reform's 56 lost councillors since May came from defection, suspension and resignation, not lost votes, while the party gained three of ten council by-elections and finished second in four more over the same fortnight. That record undercuts reading the churn as electoral retreat.

Democratic Unionist Party

Gavin Robinson rejects Sinn Féin's characterisation of the institutions as precarious, says the DUP is "committed to" delivering for the public, and will not be "goaded" into a dispute he attributes to Treasury funding rather than unionist bad faith.