Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
American Oversight
AI-generated illustration
OrganisationUS

American Oversight

US non-profit watchdog that uses public-records lawsuits to investigate government.

American Oversight took the Department of Homeland Security to court on 30 September 2026, demanding the documents that underpin Secretary Markwayne Mullin's July assertion of 250,000 non-citizen registrants.

Last refreshed: 1 October 2026 · Appears in 1 active topic

Timeline for American Oversight

#19 30 Sept

Sued DHS for the records behind the 250,000 claim

US Midterms 2026: Watchdog sues DHS over Mullin's 250,000
View full timeline →

Background

American Oversight is a non-partisan, non-profit watchdog in the United States that investigates government chiefly through public-records requests and Freedom of Information Act lawsuits. It launched in March 2017.

Its 2026 election work centres on the evidence for federal voter-fraud claims. Mullin said on 17 July that DHS had found 250,000 non-citizens on the rolls in states including California, New Jersey, Nevada and Pennsylvania. American Oversight says DHS acknowledged its records requests on 31 August but released nothing, and that the figure rested on commercial databases. It filed suit on 30 September, a day after Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington brought a similar case.

The group's method is to force the underlying documents into the open rather than argue the policy. Its suit tests whether a headline figure used to justify voter-roll checks can survive disclosure of the data behind it.

Common Questions
Who is suing DHS over the claim of 250,000 non-citizens on voter rolls?
American Oversight sued DHS under the Freedom of Information Act on 30 September 2026 for the records behind Secretary Markwayne Mullin's 17 July claim. Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington filed a similar suit on 29 September.Source: event
What is American Oversight?
A non-partisan, non-profit US watchdog that uses public-records requests and lawsuits to obtain government records. It launched in March 2017.Source: americanoversight.org
What did Markwayne Mullin claim about non-citizens on voter rolls?
On 17 July 2026 the Homeland Security Secretary said DHS had found 250,000 non-citizens on voter rolls, 190,832 of them in California. American Oversight says the figure rested on commercial databases.Source: event
Source Material