Skip to content
Welcome, thoughtbot's Giant Robots listeners!Start here
Cybersecurity: Threats and Defences
12OCT

CISA tells water plants to unplug controllers

3 min read
10:55UTC

CISA's 30 July alert says intruders reaching internet-exposed controllers at water and wastewater plants have already caused boil water notices and forced operators to run plant by hand. Its instruction is to disconnect the controllers, not to patch them.

TechnologyAssessed
Key takeaway

Check the vendor's commissioning paperwork; scanning your own address space won't find modems on networks you never registered.

CISA published an alert on 30 July reporting a significant increase in threat actors reaching internet-exposed programmable logic controllers at Water and Wastewater Systems facilities of every size⁠1. A programmable logic controller, or PLC, is the small industrial computer that opens a valve, starts a pump or holds a chlorine dose steady. Attackers have changed the passwords on these devices to lock operators out of their own plant, and altered the network addresses the devices answer on. In CISA's words, the activity "has resulted in boil water notices and sustained manual operations"⁠2.

Read that plainly and it describes staff standing at a pump doing by hand what the controller used to do, and households told to boil what comes out of the tap. CISA names no utility and identifies no attacker, so the harm arrives as a sector-wide statement that nobody outside the agency can trace to an incident, a date or a town.

The instruction to operators is to take the controllers off the public internet. Patching does not appear. Controllers of this generation carry no cryptographic identity for the engineer connecting to them, so there is no authentication design to repair and no update that would make an exposed device safe to leave exposed; the fix available is architectural, which is why it reads as an instruction to unplug.

The blind spot the alert singles out defeats the usual assurance. Vendors and integrators fit cellular modems during commissioning, the modem never reaches the asset register, and a scan of the utility's own address space comes back clean while the controller sits reachable on somebody else's. For a small utility, disconnection also removes the remote monitoring adopted precisely because it cannot staff a control room overnight, which turns a security instruction into an operating cost. ENISA, the European Union Agency for Cybersecurity, put EU drinking water and wastewater into its NIS360 risk zone for the first time on 28 May; the American version of that warning arrives written in boil water notices rather than risk scores.

Deep Analysis

In plain English

A programmable logic controller, or PLC, is a small industrial computer that opens and closes valves, runs pumps and manages other physical equipment at a water treatment plant. CISA says hackers are getting into these controllers over the internet at facilities of every size, in some cases changing the passwords so the people who run the plant get locked out, and changing the controller's network address so staff can't even find it to fix it. CISA's advice is blunt: disconnect these controllers from the internet rather than wait for a software fix, because this isn't a single bug you can patch, it's a connectivity problem. The alert confirms this has already caused boil-water notices, meaning residents in affected areas were told to boil tap water before drinking it, and forced some plants to run by hand rather than through automated controls.

Deep Analysis
Root Causes

CISA names the mechanism explicitly: vendors and integrators fit cellular modems onto PLCs during commissioning for remote diagnostics, and those modems don't appear on the asset-register scans utilities run to find internet exposure. The vendor installs the blind spot at commissioning, before any later misconfiguration has a chance to.

ENISA's NIS360 found a third of EU water utilities had never conducted a risk assessment at all; CISA's alert covers utilities 'of all sizes,' including some with mature cybersecurity processes, meaning the exposure survives even where an assessment has been done. Undocumented commissioning-time connectivity defeats both an absent assessment and a completed one.

What could happen next?
  • Risk

    Utilities that treat this as CISA's problem to patch, rather than their own asset-inventory gap, will remain exposed even after this specific campaign ends, because undocumented modems are a commissioning-process failure, not a single flaw.

  • Precedent

    CISA's disconnect-don't-patch instruction may become the template response for OT alerts where the failure is architectural rather than a single CVE.

First Reported In

Update #12 · KEV deadlines fell from 14 days to three

CISA· 3 Aug 2026
Read original →
Causes and effects
This Event
CISA tells water plants to unplug controllers
A federal agency has stated public-health harm from cyber intrusion as accomplished fact, sector-wide, without naming a single utility or attacker.
Different Perspectives
ENISA
ENISA
ENISA's 22 September threat report found only 23.8 per cent of NoName057(16)'s assessed claims were confirmed by independent availability checks, though the group produced 48 per cent of ideology-driven activity. The agency's numbers show public administration taking 31.8 per cent of attacks, mostly ideological DDoS.
LKA Hamburg
LKA Hamburg
Hamburg's State Criminal Police Office led the operation that took the KillSec leak site on 30 September, with ten countries, Europol and Eurojust. Investigators link the group to around 1,000 suspected attacks, at least 70 in Germany, and the seizure blocks access to at least 110 terabytes of victims' data.
ASOS
ASOS
ASOS said an unauthorised party reached names and contact details on third-party platforms after obtaining an employee's credentials by impersonating a trusted contact. It said it does not believe payment cards or account passwords were affected, and is investigating.
Check Point
Check Point
Check Point updated its advisory on 20 September to say its 9.8-rated VPN certificate flaw had been exploited on Spark firewalls since 12 September, five days after the advisory first appeared, and shipped fixes including R81.20 Take 166. It told customers using only pre-shared-key VPN communities they were not exposed.
Japan's National Police Agency
Japan's National Police Agency
Japan's National Police Agency and National Cybersecurity Office signed advisory AA26-281A and published it on 9 October, naming SoftEther VPN, MicroScan and office-cli and indicators detected since January 2016. Tokyo says the evidence comes from several FBI criminal investigations and that it will deepen cooperation with allies.
CISA
CISA
CISA gave federal agencies three days to fix five flaws from 2015 to 2023 on the day the China advisory named Integrity Technology Group, and set the same clock on 34 of 43 September listings. It treats a named state-linked operation as reason enough to patch old software within the week.